12

Steve Roger (the "Captain America") enlisted in the US Army as a private. Then, after undergoing the super-soldier treatment and proving himself in action he got promoted:

Col. Chester Phillips: I asked for an army and all I got was you. You are not enough.

Senator Brandt: [to Steve] With all due respect to the Colonel, I think we may be missing the point. I’ve seen you in action, Steve. More importantly, the country’s seen it. [to his aide] Paper.[the aide shows them the news paper (‘The New York Examiner’ Vol. XCVII No. 33.634, Wednesday, June 23, 1943), headlines: "Nazis in New York - mystery man saves child"] The enlistment lines have been around the block since your picture hit the newsstands. You don’t take a soldier, a symbol like that, and hide him in a lab. Son, do you want to serve your country on the most important battlefield of the war?

Steve Rogers: Sir, that’s all I want.

Senator Brandt: Then, congratulations. You just got promoted.

Well obviously, "Captain America" sounds better than "Private America" but was this promotion legal?

From the wiki article about "Battlefield promotion":

A battlefield promotion is awarded to enlisted soldiers who are promoted to a higher enlisted rank during combat or combat conditions. [...]"Battlefield promotions are predicated on extraordinary performance of duties while serving in combat or under combat conditions." It can be used to promote an individual soldier one grade, to at most staff sergeant, and has a variety of constraints.

So from that above, Steve could be at best "Sergeant America". But he became an officer:

A battlefield commission is awarded to enlisted soldiers who are promoted to the rank of commissioned officer for outstanding leadership on the field of battle. The granting of a battlefield commission has its historical predecessor in the medieval practice of the knighting or ennoblement of a plebeian combatant on the battleground for demonstration of heroic qualities in an exceptional degree. In the medieval context, this martial achievement was often one of the main restricted pathways into the sword-bearing feudal aristocracy.

From World War I to the Vietnam War, over 31,200 sailors, soldiers, Marines, and airmen had been awarded battlefield commissions. Such a commission is usually advancement from a position of non-commissioned officer to a commissioned officer, generally O-1 - Second Lieutenant, or Ensign in the Navy and Coast Guard.

So we have here a guy, who jumped not only 7 grades as a NCO but also 3 grades (from 2nd Lieutenant to Captain) without any officer training.

Was this promotion legally binding or was Steve only "honorary Captain"?

  • 1
    Well, America isn't his real name either. So it would seem obvious this was all just marketing for the recruitment offices. The question then would be, what was his actual rank? – user25738 Jan 30 at 21:36
8

Unclear.

In the movies it appears that he is actually a Captain.

In the film Captain America: The First Avenger, Steve Rogers enlists into the Army as a private (rank E-1). Upon his successful transition via the Super Soldier serum and a training period of some length, he is promoted to the literal rank of Captain (O-3), as shown by his service uniform rank insignia.

enter image description here
- Is Captain America technically a captain? Did he ever actually obtain that rank? If he is ever promoted, will he still be called a Captain ? - Quora

So it seems that the film-makers adopted the fact that he was a legitimate captain. But in the comics we cant be sure.

Beginning in World War II, the "secret identity" of Captain America was in fact his real name and enlisted rank, i.e. - Private Steve Rogers, who deliberately acted the part of a soldier so inept they couldn't even risk sending him to battle, so he remained stationed at an Army base in Virginia as a cover for his operations as Captain America.

This is where the question of Cap's "real" rank becomes tricky because of the complicated continuity. Depending on who was writing it, either Captain America was really just an Army private, or he was in fact a commissioned captain who was merely posing as an Army private as part of his cover story.

To make things even more complicated, when he is operating in the battlefield as Captain America per se, his designation as "Captain" becomes a far more grandiose title than mere rank might suggest. Owing to the advanced tactical and strategic training he has been given, in addition to his security clearance levels and combat experience, any time "Captain" America engages with the U.S. military, he does so with full operational authority over all forces. For all intents and purposes, he outranks any other military officer in the room, even if that officer is a full four-star general or admiral.

Yet despite this insane level of authority, I believe that even in the present he still formally draws pay from the U.S. military as if he was just plain old O-3 Captain Rogers.
- Is Captain America technically a captain? Did he ever actually obtain that rank? If he is ever promoted, will he still be called a Captain ? - Quora

So, according to the comics he may be either a Private or a Captain, we can't be sure.


Update: according to this source he is a captain but i doubt the credibility of this.

  • 1
    There are other superheros with Captain in their name and not members of the military, like Shazam (originally Captain Marvel). – dean1957 Jan 30 at 2:15
  • 2
    As I recall, Marvel's current Captain Marvel, Carol Danvers, actually reached the rank of Colonel, albeit in the US Air Force. – RDFozz Jan 30 at 4:39
  • 2
    @RDFozz dean is talking about DC's Captain Marvel who is called Shazam now – Ankit Sharma Jan 30 at 7:01
  • @AnkitSharma ... which is why I specified which Captain Marvel I was talking about. As dean said, the Fawcett/DC Captain Marvel isn't in the military (after all, Billy Batson is under age). – RDFozz Jan 30 at 14:19
  • I'd contend that since the question is about the movie, the answer is actually "Yes" based on the first part of this answer.. – Johnny Bones Jan 30 at 15:24
1

This question is a few months old, but I am adding an answer to point out that the Senator isn't offering Rogers a battlefield commission.

US Army officer commissions are voted on in the Senate Armed Services Committee. If an important Senator offers to make you an officer, he can get that done. Senator Brandt would just have had to speak to the War Department and then add Steve's name to the next list of names to be voted on. During WWII, the Senate was probably voting on thousands of commissions a month.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .