Spoilers about Captain America: Civil War follow:

After Tony Stark watches the video of the Winter Soldier murdering his parents, he asks Rogers if he knew about that particular history with Bucky?

Nowhere in the story prior to that scene that aspect is shared. So did Rogers say so to protect his friend, or did he actually know that Bucky killed Stark's parents before?

1 Answer 1


He actually knew. To quote my answer to this similar question on our sister site:

He learns in Captain America: The Winter Soldier.

When Captain America and Black Widow find the hidden SHIELD bunker that contains Arnim Zola's AI, one of the things that Zola explains is how HYDRA infiltrated SHIELD from the beginning. Rogers asks how that's possible and how no one found out, and Zola replies that over the years, "accidents have been made to happen".

His video screen then flashes through a series of "accidents" that he's basically admitted to being arranged by HYDRA, and the first image is that of Howard Stark.

Earlier in the movie, Black Widow had revealed that The Winter Soldier had been killing people for ~50 years.

Once Cap discovered Bucky's identity and that he's working for HYDRA, and that it was Bucky who arranged Nick Fury's "accident", it wouldn't have been much of a leap at all to figure out that he's also the one that assassinated the others Zola bragged about. (Note that when Tony first confronts him, he actually say something like "I didn't know it was him", but doesn't push the issue, implying that he didn't know for sure that Bucky was the assassin, but had come to that conclusion anyway.)

  • Now that I've been pointed to better answers, I don't think Capt America knew it was Bucky that killed Howard Stark & Mrs. Stark. He only was given this information when talking to (computerized) Arnim Zola as a newspaper headline saying "[Stark's accident] was no accident" and implies it was Hydra that ordered the Stark assassination.
    – enorl76
    Oct 8, 2018 at 20:12

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .