7

During the Dunkirk evacuation, Mr. Dawson and his crew rescued a soldier and let him board in their boat. The soldier doesn't want to go back to Dunkirk. And while arguing he accidentally hit George.

After that moment, the soldier asked Peter about him. George died after a few hours.

Why didn't Peter tell the truth to the soldier?

  • 6
    I haven't seen the movie but why would you tell a traumatised soldier he just killed an innocent man who was trying to help him? It's just common compassion. – Paulie_D Jul 20 '17 at 15:39
  • 1
    Yes clearly that: by compassion, he was already highly traumatized and we can clearly see that he was feeling culprit about the accident. – M.Polo Jul 21 '17 at 15:45
  • A sense of grace. – Ben Plont Jul 25 '17 at 5:07
9

As noted by Mr. Dawson, the soldier was suffering from shell shock, and would, "Likely never be himself again," after Peter asked if the man was a coward. It's not really the shaken soldier's fault he acted the way he did, even if it did lead to him killing an innocent civilian. His ship was torpedoed and sank, leaving him as the only survivor. He knew the dangers of heading back to Dunkirk, and lashed out in fear because of the horrors he'd experienced.

Peter, realizing this, likely felt it was better to tell him George was alright instead of risking another emotional outburst or drastic action from the shaken soldier. In the end it didn't really matter if he knew, at least at that moment, that he'd caused George's death; nothing could change that fact, but things could easily get worse now that dozens of men were on the boat.

Mr. Dawson acts as a sort of voice of reason, likely having served in World War I, and thus familiar with the ravages of war and its affect on soldiers. He even gives Peter a nod of approval for his handling of the situation.

This scene is further expanded upon in one of the closing scenes for the film, where Peter sees the shaken soldier looking at him as they carry George's body off the boat. It's left to the viewer to decide if the shaken solder knew it was George wrapped in the sheet or not, as he'd already turned and began walking away by the time Peter looked back at him a second time.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .