So the movie revolves around this girl Jay who has a new boyfriend named Hugh. They hook up, he chloroforms her and ties her up, tells her she will now be stalked by a creature who will try to kill her, gives a short explanation of how this creature works (basically works like a hot potato STD, will stalk you until you pass it on through having sex with someone else).
He seems to know some very specific things about it:
"Just sleep with someone as soon as you can. Just pass it along"
"It could look like someone you know. Or it could be a stranger in a crowd."
"But there is only one of it."
Then he lets her go and disappears from her life. They find him later and he adds more details:
"Wherever you are? Is someone walking straight towards you. But it is walking. If you try falling off. You could buy yourself some time, I think."
So like... how would he know any of this?! It really sounds like he barely knew the one he got it from, and he doesn't even know if it was her, so it is unlikely she told him anything (if she even knew):
"I met a girl at the bar. Its a one night stand. I don't even remember her name. I think that's where it came from."
Basically, how does he have so many precise details about this bizarre thing that was thrust into his life and he hasn't talked to anyone about?! Even if he has been managing it for months I find it difficult to think of scenarios where he would gain all of this complex knowledge about it...