A message from our CEO about the future of Stack Overflow and Stack Exchange. Read now.

New answers tagged


The episode with Stella's and Ted's (cancelled) wedding (Shelter Island, Season 4, Episode 5) where Barney (probably) has a threesome is after the episode about the belt (Third Wheel, Season 3, Episode 3) where Barney tells the story about his failed attempt at a threesome. So there are no mistakes in the timeline of the show.


There are a few misconceptions and assumptions in the question. It's unproven that there was a second girl in the bedroom during Ted and Stella's wedding. I don't remember this implication, having watched the show multiple times. Even if there was a third girl, the Bro Code stipulates limitations to "the tricycle". If any of these rules were violated, it ...

Top 50 recent answers are included