15

The first Captain America movie happens in the 40s. Steve falls in love with Peggy then.

In Avengers Endgame, Cap and Ironman travel to 1970. Cap sees Peggy then, she doesn't seem to have aged a day since the 40s.

How does this work, shouldn't Peggy have been 30 years older than we saw her in Captain America: The First Avenger?

  • 5
    @jared Im referring to the scene in 1970 when Steve is looking to steal Pym capsules. He sees Peggy in the next room. – MovieMe Apr 28 at 10:56
  • 8
    Perhaps she just ages really well. – Paulie_D Apr 28 at 11:48
  • 3
    I doubt there's an in-Universe explanation for this. The obvious out of universe explanations would be that the audience is supposed to recognise her, and they already had an actress for a younger Peggy so it doesn't make a lot of sense to hire another one or apply so much make up to the current one that she becomes effectively unrecognisable. – Cubic Apr 28 at 16:59
  • 3
    Hmm.. Let's just go with "ages really well", good choice Cap. :) – MovieMe Apr 28 at 17:57
  • 3
    Peggy was about 24 during First Avenger (She was born in 1921), so in the scene in 1970 she would be around 50. There is also a scene int Ant-Man, where she is presented at 68 years old, in 1989. – TK-421 Jun 25 at 10:56
6

We don't get much of a good look of her, as we only see her briefly through a window with blinds. Nonetheless, she does seem to have some streaks of grey hair and is a little wrinkley-er.

Also, she was born in 1921 (source). So in 1970, she would've been either 48 or 49. It's not implausible to me that the woman below is 48 or 49.

enter image description here

enter image description here

0

There is no direct dialogue in the film which addresses this, however there are several possibilities:

  1. This could have been an oversight in the film
  2. She did look different, it was just difficult to discern
  3. The character's use of make-up made it more difficult to discern her character's age
  4. The directors simply didn't have a good/viable/economical way to address that specific detail

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .