In the movie Margin Call (2011), once the firm realizes that they need to sell all their derivatives before the market crashes, they pressure Eric Dale (the analyst who was originally looking into this risk, who gets laid off at the beginning of the movie) into coming back to the company for a day, and pay him handsomely for doing so.

enter image description here

Why do they need him? What difference does it make that he's back at the company, especially for only one day?

1 Answer 1



  1. Eric found out that they have a lot of toxic assets
  2. They want to sell them in one day before anyone else finds out
  3. Since Eric knows everything, they want him under their control and to keep quiet
  4. They use the carrot and stick approach: Either a lot of money or ruin

Why do they need him? What difference does it make that he's back at the company, especially for only one day?

Their plan of selling the assets only works, if the potential buyers don't know that they are toxic. Eric was fired and presents a risk to the firm. He knows their secret and could tell somebody. So they want him back at the company for just one day and a lot of money to specifically do nothing - keep quiet under their control, while they sell the assets.


From wikipedia:

Cohen's plan is for the firm to quickly dump all of the toxic assets in a fire sale before the market learns of their worthlessness, thereby limiting the firm's exposure. Tuld favors the plan, comparing the economic situation to one of musical chairs: when the music stops, the last one standing will be left with only toxic, worthless securities.

And snippets from the script:

Scene 60 (71-74), Will and Seth at Eric's "very nice large townhouse":

WILL EMERSON: Jared Cohen called an emergency meeting of the partners tonight. John Tuld has decided to liquidate our entire position.


WILL EMERSON: They want me to get you back there, they are worried about you being out here.

("out here" - he was fired, is not under their control and could thwart their plans by telling someone about his discovery.)

ERIC: I signed my papers man, I'm out. They've got nothing on me anymore.

WILL EMERSON: They'll pay...

ERIC looks over at WILL. WILL lets him know with a look that they mean real money.

Their plan mentioned again (I bowdlerized it):

WILL EMERSON: True. Dumping the whole [beep] motherload in one day. [beep] up. Well... alright.

Finally, Will mentions what happens if Eric doesn't come (I had to bowdlerize again):

                     WILL EMERSON
           Tuld doesn't want any loose ends.

           They fired me Will. [beep] em... [beep] em.

                     WILL EMERSON
           Just come back with them, take the bonus,
           and you're home tonight by five. Either
           that or they are going to fight you on
           everything, the package, the options...

 ERIC drops his head.
  • This is all good except: 1. He didn't know the full picture. He was missing some details, so did they really expect him to care enough to go around spreading these rumors that he's no idea are true or not (putting his reputation at risk) and in the state of emotional distress after firing? 2. They expected to be able to finish with the sale in a day and the timeline even 60 cents/dollar around mid-day IIRC. This means there wasn't even that much time to spread that rumor (remember how long the whole cycle of reporting this irregularity to actually making the decision took?).
    – Gear54rus
    Commented May 3 at 13:58
  • It seems like a believable plot and we even got that deep conversation about the bridge but only until you think about it :)
    – Gear54rus
    Commented May 3 at 14:00

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .