23

Professor Severus Snape was a very important character throughout the Harry Potter series. He played very important roles in Harry's life as well as in Hogwarts fortune. His works were admirable and beyond expression in words.

But, with all due respect to him, I could not understand why he portrayed himself as angry, ferocious, tough and mischievous toward his students?

He always treated Harry and the students in a way which cause everyone to dislike him, except for his Slytherin students.

Why did he pretend to be so?

Was it because he could not get Lily and that Harry was the son of James, the hater of Snape?

  • 8
    He wasn't pretending. People are complicated. – OrangeDog Apr 4 '16 at 12:47
  • 2
    He's a prick, that's not evil. Per say. – cde Jul 8 '16 at 17:21
  • The real answer is that no matter how wonderful the Harry Potter series is, it's badly written. Full of plot holes, contrivances, and plain bad writing. JK wanted the audience to think Snape was evil, so she had him act evil. Ultimately it makes no sense in the end. – WakeDemons3 Mar 21 '18 at 15:39
29

Snape as a person was not very friendly or social, for that matter. His anger had a lot to do with his troubled childhood. He was a halfblood, had parental issues and was thoroughly bullied by James and Sirius at Hogwarts. This led him to develop a tough exterior.

However, Severus loved Lily deeply and had a fair share of affection for Harry too. But in Harry he saw James, a person who was used to being popular and treated as hero, and someone with utter disdain for rules.

In the end, Snape sacrifices his life for a cause and for Harry. The only reason he created that friction between himself and Harry was because he wanted Harry to be distant.

  • 9
    There's also a point to be made that he sacrifices himself and puts himself at such risk not only for Harry, but to honor Lily's memory and her sacrifice for her son. – Tablemaker Jan 18 '13 at 13:12
  • I concur. The cause I was stating is the war against the Dark Lord and the point you stated. – Sayan Jan 21 '13 at 6:16
  • Snape had parental issues? Looks like I missed that! So what is the story? – Mistu4u Jan 22 '13 at 8:11
  • @Mistu4u: Details for that are interspersed across the books. I can't remember much light being shed on it in the movies. – Sayan Jan 22 '13 at 8:55
  • 1
    @Mistu4u if it was in the movies, it was in an Occlumency lesson in Half-Blood Prince, wherein Harry (through Pensive or reversed-Legillimency) sees some of Snapes memories. – pandorym Apr 17 '13 at 17:39
12

From Snape's point of view James Potter had everything easily. He was rich, popular, clever, charismatic and he had Lilly and he made sure he rubbed Snape's face in it. The girl who Snape deeply loved had loved the man whom he hated after suffering years of persecution by him,

Snape was torn. He 'loved' Harry in a way due to Lilly but every time he saw him he was reminded of his feelings for Lilly and Lilly's feelings for James. He also seemed to find Harry reminded him of his father whom was someone Snape hated. Hence he probably did not like Harry either.

Every second he spent dealing with Harry or with Harry on his mind was deeply emotionally wounding. It is impressive he remained as composed as he did.

  • 2
    The situation with Snape and Lilly is slightly more complicated than this answer shows. He and Lilly were good friends up until the point where Snape's friendship with other Slytherins (future Death Eaters) results in a conversation where he calls Lilly a mudblood, offending her and driving her away. Up until that point, Lilly had defended him against James Potter and his friends. Afterward, she becomes part of their group, eventually dating and then marrying James. – Donald.McLean Jul 3 '13 at 18:14
  • True, I did simplify things slightly in my answer but I still think it is valid. – Stefan Jul 3 '13 at 21:12
10

Severus was not a mudblood. He was a half blood with a pureblood mother from the Prince line; The Halfblooded Prince.

Lily was a childhood friend of his, a crush, and most likely the bitter man's one true love. He told Lily about magic and she was probably Snape's best friend for most of his (early) life.
When they became estranged later in their Hogwarts career, and Lily became romantically involved with James Potter, Snape developed a bitter resentment. He fell in with the wrong crowd and he joined the Death Eaters, at the height of their power.
When Sibyl Trelawney gave the prophecy1 to Dumbledore at the Hog's Head, Snape was listening at the door, overhearing the first two lines before being caught.

"The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches...Born to those who have thrice defied him, born as the seventh month dies..."

This gave Voldemort all he needed to narrow down which two children it could be; Neville Longbottom or Harry Potter.

Once Snape realized that he had caused Voldemort to focus on Lily, James, and baby Harry, he panicked. While he begged for Lily's life, he probably wasn't too concerned about James Potter. Snape confessed to Dumbledore, expressed his remorse, and rejoined the side of the light as a spy for the Order of the Phoenix.

When Harry arrives at Hogwarts a decade later, Snape shows that he hates Harry on principle; Harry looked like a carbon copy of his father, who was Snape's bully.
Harry did have a habit for rule breaking:

  • stealing from Snape's stores in the second year
  • fighting trolls
  • sneaking around with an invisibility cloak
  • even allowing Sirius Black to escape once Snape had caught him.

This made it easier for Snape to see more of James in Harry, and less of the intelligent Lily Evans who was a dedicated student.
It should be noted that Snape did watch out for Harry. While he was caustic and deplorable as an educator, he did look after Harry, locking a broom jinx in first year, and all of his acts as a spy in bringing down Voldemort.

Snape was a spy. Most of the Slytherin students were the children of Death Eaters. Like Dumbledore, Snape anticipated the rise of Voldemort as an eventuality. He needed to preserve his position as a spy. Playing nice with Hufflepuffs and especially Gryffindors would have hurt his image, especially with the Death Eater parents.
He portrayed himself as aligned with the dark side because that was his job as a spy. He had years to ingratiate himself with them, even becoming Draco Malfoy's godfather.

So in summary, Snape is so angry with Harry in particular because he is petty in a sense; punishing the son for the sins of a father he never knew. He's ferocious with the other houses and is only nice to his Slytherins because he needs to preserve his role as a spy.

5

" I could not understand why he portrayed himself as angry, ferocious, tough and mischievous to his students? "

  • First, among other things, because he was a high-IQ, low-social-IQ geek, who had to develop a tough bullying exterior to survive all his life.

    He clearly hated incompetents (thus total offense at Neville's entire existence). He disliked Gryffindors since he saw nothing but grief from them all his life.

    He doted on his in-group (Slytherins) - clearly illustrated when he forsake Lily and her love for being with his budding-DE Slytherin friends when in school.

  • Second, because that tough pro-Slytherin image was helpful to him as far as convincing Death Eaters that he was still on their sides. He was "in" with Lucius Malfoy and other Slytherin DE parents, and playing favorites helped him in that even if he wasn't naturally inclined to do so, which he was (see #1)

  • 1
    +1 For the last point, I was going to say that! Further evidence is the way he behaves when he is alone with Dumbledore (pensieve memories) - he cries etc. – Möoz Oct 27 '14 at 20:24
2

He always treated Harry and the students in a way which cause everyone to dislike him, except for his Slytherin students.

Was it because he could not get Lily and that Harry was the son of James, the hater of Snape? Why did he pretend to be so?

Well, apart from not being very friendly at all, Severus loved Harry in a strange way. He was the son of the woman he loved his entire life, and that's why he protected him. But from the moment he met Harry, except for his eyes, he was a mini-copy of James. Everyone told him that he was a little copy of James but had his mother's eyes. So seeing "James" all around was really difficult for him after all he's been through. Especially when little Harry opened his mouth and became a little sassy. Severus had the upper hand this time though, and that's why he was a little 'cruel'. Don't forget that when we read about Snape finding out about Lily's death and the survival of her son -- Harry -- he said that he wanted to do anything to protect her and not her child or husband. Those were words of grief though, and once more, Dumbledore reasoned with him and he managed to protect Harry until his last breath.

1

James Potter bullied Severus Snape during their year in Hogwarts, so naturally, Snape developed a disliking for him. And also, he was head over heals with Lily but the girl whom he loved deeply, had chosen James over him. Harry is Lily and James's son, he behaves like his father and his hair is messy like his father's but he has his mother's eyes,thus whenever Snape sees him, he is reminded of Lily and James, but Harry broke a couple of school rules, which reminded him mostly of James, whom he despised instead of Lily, whom he loved.

1

Snape was dealt a bad set of cards. His childhood best friend falls in love with, who he considered, a rich pompous bully. It's his fault that Voldemort interprets the prophecy by Trelawney to mean that Harry will be his downfall. He essentially signed Lily's death warrant. Guilt and remorse motivates him to protect Harry but I think years of working undercover (which probably included torture and murder) changed him. The life of a double agent must be lonely. When Voldemort comes back after his demise, he's asked to return to the dark ranks. He's bitter and alone.

The movies don't depict the actors ages correctly. Snape becomes a Death Eater after school (around age 18) and his best friend dies 2 years later. He'll have about 10 years of peace before he returns to espionage and dies at age 38.

Snape's role during this entire time was extremely sensitive and required master espionage and image-control skills. As he and Dumbledore anticipated that Voldemort would return eventually, and many of Snape's actions would be reported on by Death Eater spies or gained through torture and Legilimency, even if Snape's true mentality and intentions were inaccessible to the Dark Lord, he had to consider every decision and relationship carefully. He treated Harry Potter with maximal coldness and never missed an opportunity to cause him trouble, as any variation from this would have cast suspicion on him in Voldemort's eyes.

Taken from Harry Potter Wikia

  • What on earth is happening with your last paragraph being one whole link? Were you trying to link on one part or something? Let us know if you need any assistance with formatting. – Möoz Jan 12 '18 at 0:41
  • 1
    @Möoz Looks like it. I changed it into block quotes. – Nog Shine Jan 12 '18 at 3:58
  • I recently joined and did not look at the formatting before I published. Thanks for the fix @NogShine – doctordonna Jan 12 '18 at 21:41

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .