8

Off-late, many people on Facebook have been sharing this particular still from DDLJ. It seems funny or logical? Why didn't Simran get into bogey from first door? Does director want to show LOVE IS BLIND? Or director seized the opportunity for Simran to take the longer route (she's in Love, my boy) and thereby accomplish the feat of stretching the climax by 2-3 more minutes?

enter image description here

  • Its a movie mistake question.......and doesnot have a answer just speculation at viewer point of view. – Ankit Sharma Dec 24 '12 at 6:27
  • The term suspension of disbelief or willing suspension of disbelief has been defined as a willingness to suspend one's critical faculties and believe the unbelievable; sacrifice of realism and logic for the sake of enjoyment. – chaitanya89 May 4 '17 at 11:01
5

As noted, this is only speculation, but the woman is not running to catch a train, she is running to a man who looks to be waiting to help her aboard. Logically, she could have taken the first door, but if this is a romance, it would not be the romantic choice. I don't think this is an accident by the film-maker, but a confirmation of her intent and the intent of the film.

  • Looks like an appropriate answer. – Ankit Sharma Feb 6 '15 at 6:49
  • Yes this one of top grossing romantic movie :-) in India. – Panther Apr 18 '17 at 10:17
3

Personally I believe it is an unintentional error by the director. Now the viewers observes a lot more than a director thinks. But if I am to cover the director I would say, it really depends upon the way a person thinks. Generally ladies are said to like taking decision by heart rather than by brain and it is true. May be if this was SRK in place of Kajol as the runner, he might have entered by the last gate! I feel at that particular moment Simran was so eager to meet Raj in that situation, she did not think about it.

But if I see it logically, it is a foolish mistake by the makers. They should have made him stand in the last door of the bogey.

2

This is not an unintentional error by the makers of the film. There might be two reasons for this scene.

  1. Here Simran's destination is not the train but Raj. By this scene, he wanted to show how desperate the love between the actor and actress. She didn't look at other ways. Only thing she could see is Raj his love. This is what the director and writer wanted to convey to the audience. One of the producers and writers of this movie is Late Yash Chopra. He is called the King of Romance. He is renowned as the director who taught Romance and unconditional love to Bollywood. So we can't ignore his part in filming this episode.

  2. The velocity factor: It is difficult to board a moving train. We can board a moving train with some help. Since Raj is stretching his hand to help Simran boarding train, she is running towards him help to board the train.

1

Who thinks that the director is mistaken is foolish or stupid? He wanted to show how the romance looks like. The scene came earlier in the movie when they were strangers and later when they are lovers. If she entered from the first gate the movie would have lost its eternality and a scene repeated more than 100 times and one of the best ending with the best music. It would have been dry, dull and free from romance.

  • 1
    What does eternalittle means? Is it really a english word? – Ankit Sharma Nov 3 '13 at 21:46
  • @AnkitSharma I'd say it should have been "etern a little", still that's just a guess and I'm not sure what "etern" is either. – Napoleon Wilson Nov 3 '13 at 22:34

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .