12

In Deadpool 2, there is a brief moment (couple of seconds) where we see X-Men trying to hide from Deadpool when he is in the mansion.

However, in this scene we see James Mcavoy in the role of Prof. Xavier.

Assuming Deadpool is not in 80's or 90's (he is well in 2010's) then shouldn't Patrick Stewart have played this role?

Or should it be assumed that James Mcavoy has taken 100 % of this role and now he will play the older version too?

So how is this timeline matching?

  • You mean in end credit scenes when he was time traveling ? – Ankit Sharma May 22 '18 at 6:55
  • 2
    @AnkitSharma No, in movie. When Beast quietly closes the door behind Deadpool. – Faizan Rabbani May 22 '18 at 6:57
  • I don't think Deadpool fits in any timeline. Deadpool is that Marvel movie that is only for entertainment purpose - with silly jokes and sometimes real-time references. E.g if you remember, in the beginning Deadpool mentions about Logan's death. So in all, Deadpool doesn't fit in any MCU's timelines. – HardikT May 22 '18 at 13:40
  • 1
    Funfact: Patrick Stewart had stated (before DP2's production began!) that the only time he would return to the franchise would be in Deadpool! What a missed opportunity :( – John Smith Optional May 22 '18 at 15:48
  • 2
    Have you noticed that when Deadpool wears the Cerebro helmet, he complains that "it smells like Patrick Stewart"? – Yasskier May 22 '18 at 22:32
9

So how is this timeline matching?

It doesn't.

It's just a two part joke thrown in due to fortunate timing and the availablity of the current X-men actors.

It was joke from the first Deadpool movie that the school was empty even though it should be overflowing with recognisable mutants.

At the time this was due, mostly, to the character "permissions" being tightly controlled and budget issues but now this is not such an issue.

However, the previous iterations of the X-men actors aren't available (Jackman a possible exception) but fortunately, the new versions, it so happened, were.

So...

A scripted joke got enhanced...

Director David Leitch told us how the shot came together. “That was interesting because Simon Kinberg was filming X-Men: Dark Phoenix in Montreal at the same time we were doing Deadpool,” he told Den of Geek. “So this was in the script but we were always wondering how we were going to be able to pull it off. The set supervisor, Dan Glass, who did the Matrix films, he came up with this idea of doing a composite, and getting the plates to match.

“So we shot our side here, and we sent the measurements and the camera positions and things up to Simon's team on Dark Phoenix, and they shot the plate for that there,” continued Leitch. “Then we put the two together. So actually it turned out to be easier than we thought. If we would have had to get all those people in the room it probably wouldn't have happened.

Source

  • When you say 'Marvel (mostly) has these back...' in terms of rights... you are aware both X-men and Deadpool aren't owned by Marvel Studios, right? they're both owned by Fox and have always been in the same rights stable, hence Wade Wilson's inclusion in the Wolverine film. – John Smith Optional May 22 '18 at 15:32
  • Are you aware that Marvel has concluded a deal ....to buy Fox. vox.com/culture/2017/12/14/16738852/… and uk.businessinsider.com/… – Paulie_D May 22 '18 at 15:34
  • @JohnSmithOptional is definitely right here, neither Deadpool or the X-Men were officially owned by Marvel Studios at time of filming or Release. There is a deal on the table but It has not been finalised and the rights to the Fox owned marvel characters are nowhere near Marvel Studios hands. The actual reason for there being no X-men in the X Mansion in the first movie is because Fox were reluctant to make Deadpool and as a result there was a low budget. This was rectified in Deadpool 2 due to the critical success of the original so they were able to get more X-men for the cameo. – DannyJames May 22 '18 at 15:38
  • 1
    Well, yes... but no. DISNEY have started the acquisition of Fox, but that's irrelevant entirely... Deadpool and X-men have never had any rights restrictions in their cross pollination, and at the time of production Disney weren't necessarily in the frame. – John Smith Optional May 22 '18 at 15:38
  • Yes, Disney's deal is not finalized and Fox head says they will proceed as business as usual until it is. Deadpool has been thought of being in it's own timeline/universe. It's just has permission to "touch" on events in X-Men films being "meta" in nature, unlike like Legion and the Gifted that are in parallel universe further removed from knowlege of the main X-Men films. It's a way to tell different kinds of X-Men stories and not be beholden to each other. comicbook.com/marvel/2017/01/26/… – Darth Locke May 22 '18 at 15:46
-6

I think you've missed the joke.

Deadpool did not see the X-Men. Deadpool saw the actors (and filming equipment).
The next X-movie will not be contemporary of Deadpool.

If I remember correctly the next X-movie will be set in the 80/90

-8

Yeah, " assuming Deadpool is not in 80's or 90's". You could also assume Deadpool is on the moon and ask "If he's on the moon why there's air and trees?"

We didn't know Deadpool timeline. UNTIL that scene set DP in the X-men continuity and the 90's. This scene was directed BY "Dark Phoenix" director in postproduction to place Diddy Pe in universe.

DirtyPolly is known to not be aligned with one time and timeline. Or Universe. Or even publisher franchise. This anchor is something that don't need to be very crucial for this particular character.

  • Don't forget Colossus is with DP in that scene, how do you explain that? – Faizan Rabbani May 22 '18 at 8:34
  • In scene, yes. In same frame? No. Think about that like Tyler Durden – SZCZERZO KŁY May 22 '18 at 8:55
  • Are you proposing that Colossus is imaginary in that scene? – Faizan Rabbani May 22 '18 at 9:00
  • No, the X-men. Or not imaginary. he joke in D1 was that in so big mansion there are only Teenage and Ironballs. In d2 we see they are there just not in Deadpool vision. Kind like "Others" (or Dark Souls) or those old comedy bits when people look for each other and enter the same room at different time so they don't notice each other. – SZCZERZO KŁY May 22 '18 at 9:08

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .