I was re-watching Sin City (2005) and noticed in the opening credits that Quentin Tarantino was listed as "Special Guest Director". This intrigued me, so I have a two part question (somewhat related).

  1. What does a guest (or special guest) director do? What is their job? Like an adviser/consultant or do they just get paid to have their name in the credits?

  2. What exactly did Quentin do in this movie, what were his contributions? And is this typical of movies with guest directors?

  • 1
    AFAIK, guest directors direct a scene from a movie. Guest directing (for directors) is comparable to cameos (made by actors). I've seen it used a lot in recent Marvel movies where a director of a feature film also [guest-]directs a scene in another feature film. For example Taika Waititi director of Thor: Ragnarok was a guest director in Doctor Strange because he directed the mid-credit scene featuring Thor. Feb 4, 2018 at 3:12

1 Answer 1


Tarantino was invited to direct a scene in "Sin City" (2005) by his friend and the film's co-director, Robert Rodriguez. As Tarantino generally has no interest in the use of digital cinematography, Rodriguez encouraged him to film part of 'The Big Fat Kill' so that his friend would have a chance to experiment with the format, with real actors, and all the smorgasbord of features available on a studio production. Per Variety, Tarantino was "paid exactly $1" to direct the scene. This is not at all typical for guest directors. It may be considered typical of Tarantino and Rodriguez, as Tarantino paid Rodriguez $1 to compose the score for "Kill Bill Vol. 2" (2004).

The scene which Tarantino shot and directed would have given him the option to become involved in the framing and lighting of the scene (Rodriguez acted as Cinematographer for the entire film), and to get the performances from the two actors (Clive Owen, Benicio del Toro).

This is discussed on the second feature commentary included with the Special Edition release of the film on DVD & Blu - Ray.

IMDB's trivia section also includes the following:

The scene that Quentin Tarantino directed is the drive to the pits scene in which Dwight (Clive Owen) talks with a very dead Jackie Boy (Benicio Del Toro). When Tarantino insisted on a real car being built for the shooting Robert Rodriguez told him that it would be easier without one. After shooting a few takes with the real car, Tarantino realized his friend was right. Tarantino also came up with the idea of Jackie Boy's slit throat affecting his speech and Dwight speaking his internal monologue rather than dubbing it in later.

and that

Robert Rodriguez scored Kill Bill: Vol. 2 (2004) for one dollar. Quentin Tarantino said he would repay him by directing a segment of this movie for one dollar. Tarantino, a vocal proponent of film-over-digital, has said that he was curious to get hands-on experience with the HD cameras which Rodriguez lauds. When asked about his experience, Tarantino merely replied, "Mission Accomplished".


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .