3

In Once Upon a Time in the West, Frank says 'who are you?' before dying, revealing that he doesn't know who Harmonica is.

So if he didn't know Harmonica was coming, who sent the three gunmen to kill him in the opening scene?

7

Frank knew that Harmonica was coming. Because Harmonica told Frank he will come.

  • Harmonica asks the three guys "where's Frank?"
  • Then he asks if they have brought a horse for him.

This shows that he announced himself prior to coming. Probably even saying on which train he will come. Frank was expecting him (perhaps not knowing who he really was, though.)

Frank is aware of Harmonica's existence and (later) his pursuit to kill him. He is just curious why. A better constructed, reversed "it was Tuesday" trope.

You see, not knowing who his opponent was and what were his motives left Frank without leverage. He mocked people, laughed at their weakness. Having this mysterious person who only says names of people Frank killed leaves him open as dead people don't have soft spots.

2

Harmonica had contacted in advance a man named Wobbles (interpreted by Marco Zuanelli) to arrange a meeting with Frank:

[Harmonica] You know, Wobbles... I'm kinda mad at you. Frank wasn't there.
[Wobbles] Ow!
[Harmonica] He sent three friends.
[Wobbles] I don't know nothing, I swear. I only arranged the meeting the way... the way you wanted it. I don't know why Frank wasn't there.

Given Frank did not know Harmonica, he probably found the meeting suspicious and decided to send the three gunmen to neutralize the potential threat.

  • Frank: “So you're the man who makes appointments.” Harmonica: “And you're the man who doesn't keep them.” – Anton Sherwood Apr 30 at 8:06
1

Harmonica has obviously been chasing Frank for a while, hence the trap at the start of the movie.

Frank is merely wondering why Harmonica is so eager to kill him.

  • Sure, Harmonica has been chasing Frank but if Frank knew he was being chased and knew he would be on the train at the beginning (surely he wouldn't stake out EVERY train, just in case) then he would have known who he was and why he wanted to kill him. If he knew who Harmonica was he wouldn't be wondering why Harmonica wants to kill him so it seems clear to me that he didn't know who he was; hence his question "Who are you?"" before he dies. Which means he couldn't have set a trap for him in the opening scene. – Glenn Evans Jan 26 '18 at 7:17
  • "then he would have known who he was and why he wanted to kill him" Why would he? He's a bad guy, and now he has someone chasing him. Frank simply needs Harmonica dead. Also note that the assassins are pretending to be Cheyenne's men. – BCdotWEB Jan 26 '18 at 10:29

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .