14

Sound designer Ben Burtt has worked on 7 Star Wars films as a sound designer. He claims that his favorite sound is from the 1938 film The Adventures of Robin Hood.

My favorite sound is the "Robin Hood Arrow" from the 1938 Adventures of Robin Hood. I have many favorites. I could write a book on the ones I love and their stories.

IMDb claims that the "Robin Hood Arrow" was used in almost all of the Star Wars films.

The sound of Robin's arrow is the favorite sound of Skywalker Sound's Ben Burtt. He has used that sound in almost all the Star Wars films.

Is this claim by IMDb true? If so, which sounds from the Star Wars films feature the "Robin Hood Arrow"?

  • Don't suppose you have a link to the sound itself? – jscs Dec 23 '17 at 16:52
3

I am only citing sources, I cannot confirm their accuracy even though I tried a great deal as it's really hard to find any info or sources to back any of this up. Including Ben supposedly using the sound in Star Wars as where this is quoted on other sites seems to be exactly the same as the IMDB one, as if that is the original source.

There is a potential similar sound if you listen to the above original sound at higher speed (x 1.5), then some of the Ewok scenes at low speed (X 0.75). At the start of the arrow firing it has a similar resonance and sound, but is hard to identify with any degree of accuracy with my basic equipment (youtube/browser).

The difference could be that Ben speeded it up or played around with it, adding more electronic effects (which weren't available 40ish years previous). Or perhaps with Ben being expert in this specific field he could have entirely (re)created it himself.

It could also be that it was a different arrow sound to the one above taken from the original Robin Hood, or of course the IMDB quote could just be wrong.

You could perhaps try contacting Skywalker Sounds (at the bottom) or IMDB and see if they can verify the quote.

 


Additional trivia I found along the way:

In an interview (written), Ben Burtt stated:

Being a young boy, of course I loved action, you know, Westerns, and things with explosions in it, and violence, all the things that interest boys at that age. So what I meant was that when there was something well done—a great fight scene, with punching sounds, or gunshots, or airplanes—it was exciting to hear. One of my favorite films was The Adventures of Robin Hood with Errol Flynn.

And it had the great sound of the arrows in that movie. I went outside with my own bow and arrow, and it didn’t sound anything like the one in Robin Hood. And so I got really interested: Well, what was that sound? My bow and arrow didn’t have this beautiful, almost musical sound as the arrow flew through the air. And so I began to realize that the sounds in movies were enhanced in some way, there was something different about them.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .