8

Ever since i saw the movie back in 2003 (i was very young) i couldn't understand what Gandalf meant. Later i also read all Tolkien's books about Middle Earth, Arda etc.. Tolkien did write this exact phrase in the book. It is written precisely:

Gandalf put his hand on Pippin's head. 'There never was much hope,' he answered. 'Just a fool's hope, as I have been told. And when I heard of Cirith Ungol———'.

So what exactly is the meaning?

What i think: Maybe he refers to the futility of life, and the insignificant strives of humans to find meaning and hope? But it's only a fool's errand.

Sure there's room for interpretation, but i want to know if there's somebody who is more informed than me, or understands what exactly is meant here. Thanks.

  • 2
    i think that you guys are over thinking this. he means that they are fools to stand against sauron, but because they were standing against sauron they still had hope – Jack Cantorna Jan 9 '18 at 3:48
  • @JackCantorna - I don't think it was as general as just opposing Sauron. Taking the Ring into Mordor to defeat him? That might be deemed as "foolish," for sure. "One does not just walk into Mordor...." – PoloHoleSet Jan 10 '18 at 15:06
9

But it's only a fool's errand.

This is it....something so impossible that only a fool would think it even worth doing, only a bigger fool would attempt it....and only a fool would hope it could work.

The fool's hope here is the taking of the ring to Mordor for destruction.

Frodo’s mission is impossible. Even if the Fellowship had not been broken at the Falls of Rauros and Aragorn and Boromir, Legolas and Gimli had been at Frodo’s side on the journey to Mount Doom it would have remained impossible.

...and that's why it's a pivotal point of the story.

This short but very illuminating scene from the final Lord Of The Rings trilogy, “Return Of The King” hits an important theme, hope. When the young hobbit asks the ever wise Gandalf if there was any hope, he was initially shocked to hear the wizard tell him that there never really was much hope to begin with. And then he follows up by laying out the most profound portion of this speech/scene….”Just a fool’s hope”. The reason this moment serves as a pivotal part of the movie is because Gandalf refers to a “fool” as someone who technically is not “too smart for his own good” type of individual – an ironic characteristic the hobbit always had, that wasn’t necessarily ever really a bad thing. It’s often the ones who have this blind faith, because they don’t know any better

source

2

Just to add to the answer from @Paulie_D - the 'fool' Gandalf is talking about here is himself. He is the one who dreamed up the scheme and hoped it would work.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .