0

My question is to seek an explanation about the scene with special forces. I couldn't think of any possible plot advancement or plot changes that the scene depicted.

Let's take a quick recap. Fox and Miranda were held captive and they both knew the bomb was timed. Blake took Jones to meet Fox secretly in order to brief him about the "updated info" on the bomb. When Fox was just about to brief Jones regarding the timed nature of the bomb, Blake said, "here comes the important part" (which clearly shows that Blake knows that the bomb is timed and it will go off regardless of anything). Jones hearing the brief said to Blake that we'll handle it from here leading to the fighting scene with Bane and died.

So Blake, knowing all, could tell Jones even before coming to the meeting that bomb was timed. Why didn't he? Even Blake said to Miranda that someone sold us out but she was seen later with Gordon confronting Foley so they even didn't doubt her due to this episode. So why put this scene with no purpose served to the plot?

I already had a discussion with Flater on his answer about what could've been done by the army to save the city (plot changes), using the information provided in the film (not in-universe, I think). I do seek the fit in the plot about this scene.

There are many scenes in a movie but they all contribute to the plot. An example is from Dark Knight where Joker burnt all the cash to second Alfred's point that "some people just wanna watch the world burn" and as he himself said, "...it is to send a message". So it gives insight about the Joker (that he can't be bought) and further contributed to the plot of the movie.

So, why Blake took Jones to meet Fox only to know the bomb is timed while Blake already knows it? There must be a reason for this scene or a significance, not just tangentiality.

  • 1
    I'm voting to close this question as off-topic because the OP tries to rewrite the plot when faced with in-universe justifications. This makes the question unanswerable without having to provide feedback to alternate plot possibilties that the OP presents as "counterevidence". – Flater Sep 18 '17 at 11:11
  • @Flater Sorry, I disagree. I intend to know the reason (a plausible one) why Blake took Jones to meet Fox? Comments to your answer were in hope of further understanding/discussing your answer (logic), to which I still don't find myself agreeable. – Najam Sep 18 '17 at 11:26
2

Jones wouldn't have died if they both told him earlier in the secret meet up and the army outside the city would've devised another strategy, perhaps not blocking the bridges/tunnels and letting people out.

This is highly unlikely. The bridges and tunnels were being barricaded by the army because they had been explicitly told that the bomb would be set off if anyone escaped over the bridge.

Even with the bomb on a timer, that doesn't quite change the scenario. If anyone crosses that bridge, the bomb will be set off (regardless of whether there was a timer or not).

You also have to consider it from the army's point of view, or more specifically, the soldiers on site. If they allow people to cross the bridge, they condemn the other citizens of Gotham to die in the explosion. No person wants to make that call and have the blood on their hands.

Why Blake took Jones to meet Fox only to know the bomb is timed while Blake already knows it?

Just because we see a short meeting, does not mean that there was no other discussion taking place during that meeting.

Not everything is shown in a movie, because they need to fit an entire plot in the movie. The meeting scene could have been shortened in editing, thus omitting further details that Fox gave Jones about the bomb (expected blast radius, possible fallout, ...) because that knowledge wasn't needed for the plot to continue (it's tangential at best).

  • People can be led off in any another way, it was just a suggestion. My key question was the irrelevancy of Jones and Fox meeting; the whole scene in fact. What purpose did it fulfill? – Najam Sep 17 '17 at 6:44
  • Adding to above comment, Fox can also provide an alternative to stop triggering the bomb (the thing he took out from "The Bat", which was later used by Gordon) so even Bane or Talia cannot trigger the bomb hence facilitating the people to escape. – Najam Sep 18 '17 at 6:27
  • @Najam: Note that the alternative only stops the manual trigger, not the timed detonation. The timed detonation isn't really "intentional", it's the expected time for the reactor to explode because it has been unstable ever since it was taken by Bane. Batman only appears back in Gotham when the timer is already critically low (for obvious plot tension reasons). Fox has always kept a "don't want to know" attitude about Bruce's activities, so it stands to reason that Fox doesn't know where the Bat car is stored, and doesn't have access to it until Batman re-emerges. – Flater Sep 18 '17 at 8:05
  • Thanks for detailed explanation, but I think this Reactor thing was quite public then and Fox can share with Gordon or Blake how to disarm it since it'd have nothing to do with Batman. So he can use his excellent techy skills (and Wayne's resources in secret) to come up with a diffuser after a while the army would have taken over which would take 2-3 days max. I mean it can be well coordinated and executed since they have 23 days to do it. – Najam Sep 18 '17 at 11:03
  • Sorry for being so specific but I think the scene was unnecessary (to me) and there may be ways of saving the city without Batman. Imagine if this would be done, how would Bruce felt reaching Gotham after sickening work effort :). Btw I loved the trilogy. – Najam Sep 18 '17 at 11:03

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .