4

In Stranger Things, Nancy calls Barbara Holland's mother on the next day after the pool party. Mrs. Holland is expecting her daughter to have slept over at Nancy's. Nancy makes up an obvious lie, but Mrs. doesn't seem to give it too much thought. She doesn't seem to be shown worrying about Barbara any time later, even after she's been missing for days.

When Will's mother and the sheriff come upon her in Upside Down, they just pass her, not even attempting to resuscitate her, unlike Will. We don't see any implication that her parents are grieving when Will is found or after the one month timeskip.

Why is this happening?

  • 7
    Resuscitate her? Didn't Eleven already confirmed that she is dead ? – Ankit Sharma Sep 6 '17 at 8:36
  • 1
    But they attempted to save Will, even though he looked no better at the time. – Worse_Username Sep 6 '17 at 8:38
  • 1
    They went there because Eleven confirmed he is alive few minutes back and Barb was confirmed dead way back. – Ankit Sharma Sep 6 '17 at 8:39
  • 1
    Yeah, but then the demigorgon got him and now he looked no better than Barbara, who was confirmed dead. – Worse_Username Sep 6 '17 at 8:40
  • 3
    No, Barb looked way worse, vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/strangerthings8338/images/2/21/… – Ankit Sharma Sep 6 '17 at 8:41
11

Why does almost everyone neglect Barbara Holland?

Did the rest even cared in start?

Barb seems to be the least popular girl in school and shown to have only single friend Nancy. And Nancy did all that for her only.

Mr. & Mrs. Holland had very minmal role, so we don't even see them much. And she presumably believed Nacny's lie that's why she was not worried that time But Mr and Mrs Holland do go to Wheelers' house after they know about her being missing:

enter image description here

During the sensory deprivation tank scene Eleven confirmed that Barb is dead and we can see how that affected Nancy and now she just want to kill the monster in revenge.

Nobody told anything about Upside Down to her parents so we can't know how they are dealing with it, most probably in grief of her absence behind the scenes.

They just pass her, not even attempting to resuscitate her

Was there anything left to resuscitate?

enter image description here

Barb was no different then other corpse to them and grieving for her seems irrelevant as both don't even know her well. Will is her son, she will for sure do way more for him then some random corpse. And Will was in better state then Barb at many level and don't show sign of decomposition like her:

enter image description here

We don't see any implication that her parents are grieving when Will is found or after the one month timeskip.

Because it doesn't matter for the creator to show them grieving, maybe they will in second season or maybe not.

Spoilers from second season

We got introduced with Murray Bauman, disgraced journalist-turned-conspiracy theorist who was personally investigating the Hawkins mystery and then later got hired by Barb's parents. Which also cleared that Barb's parents still thinks she is missing to that point.

Even Nancy was so pumped up to give Barb justice and she did got succeed with the help of Jonathan and Murray to get revenge from DoE. And Barb get a official funeral.

But it seems that Barb was supposed to be a small character only but her popularity and justice for Barb made them mention her again more prominently.

  • 5
    Good answer. Worth noting that her parents don't actually know that she's dead. Even after enough time has passed that Nancy's lie no longer satisfies them, all they really know is that she's missing. Her body certainly won't ever be discovered. But I agree, within the time frame of season 1 and considering that they are accessory characters at best, the reactions we see are appropriate to what they know at the time. – Steve-O Sep 6 '17 at 13:42
  • There's season 2 in the works. I think it's possible that it will have people going to Upside Down again. – Worse_Username Sep 6 '17 at 16:11
4

In Season 2 Barb's parents have put their house up for sale to fund a PI to investigate her disappearance. Nancy and Jonathan get proof of what happened to Barb and with the PI release it to the public and it shuts down the lab. It isn't the full truth that's made public as that would be tough to believe. Instead, they give the explanation a chemical from the lab killed Barb and the company covered up her death. Steve and Nancy have been having weekly dinners with Barb's parents as they are still clearly obsessed with finding her and haven't accepted that she is gone. The guilt that they're selling their home to find her deeply affects Nancy and she snaps at Steve for not caring and carrying on lying when they know what happened.

  • I wonder if this is the writers responding to criticism. – Worse_Username Oct 31 '17 at 8:12
  • Possibly; they may have intended Barb's killing to just highlight the danger and heighten the stakes. They overlooked the issue of a minor's disappearance not being investigated/concluded isn't logical. – user76639 Nov 3 '17 at 0:59
0

Although this isn't yet a strong answer, the following may be a point of interest, depending on what it exactly means.

We know there was huge campaign for: Justice for Barb and the Duffer Brothers did promise this would addressed.

KFC Dinner with Barb's Parents

As one of the previous answer's sites, season 2 does feature a subplot in which Nancy seeks to avenge Barb and does address the state of Barb's parents. However season two also does some other interesting things by giving viewers a decant and morally conscious scientist in Dr. Owens, and despite Brenner's missteps and abuses towards Eleven (and Eight), it once again reinforces that the scientist are only partially responsible for Barb's death, as it was Eleven whom accidentally blew open a hole to the other dimension and that the scientist themselves do not understand the nature of the Upside Down. This makes the actions of Nancy not necessarily better for Hawkins and it's residents, because we see Dr. Owens sincerely or genuinely trying to be helpful and be more honest about what they do and do not know. So in theory, should Dr. Brenner still be alive, the Hawkins Lab, now under investigation, may remove Owens and reinstate Brenner, seeing Owens as a bigger screw-up. (The reason this relevant is because it remains to be seen how Nancy's choices towards wanting 'Justice for Barb' effects everything, which may tell us, eventually, if this action really is justice or not--subjectively, speaking.)

The other interesting things the season may have done to touch on Barb might have to do with "B" alliteration. Two of the new characters, Billy and Bob both have "B" first names, with Bob being in parallel by being a somewhat geeky innocent character that didn't deserve to die from spawn of Demigorgon, and whose name is similar sounding to Barb's. Curiously Bob also tells Will about his dreams, being intimated by an antagonistic-figure, which he refers to as Mr. Boldo (again "B" alliteration).

Nancy

Not Barb

In addition Nancy comes across a person that looks like Barb from the back, whose not Barb (possibly a 'Ghostbuster' allusion or pun -- and Nancy is also wearing "Barb" colors, as is the Not-Barb) and when Eleven goes and stays with Eight in the warehouse, there the name "Barbelith" graffitied on a wall, which is also a reference to Grant Morison's The Invisables comic. (I will come back with a screen cap, if I can find one).

Barbelith art

Note: Scientist have to go into Upside Down to fix Upside Down version of a satiate to get there equipment to better work.

In The Invisibles, Barbelith is the name of the "placenta" for humanity; a satellite-like object located on the dark side of the moon. It recurs throughout the story as a supernatural moon seeming both intelligent and benign. Barbelith's role is like that of a placenta in that it connects the hologram of our subjective reality to the realm outside of our space-time, the domain of the magic mirror, and helps humans to realize their true nature beyond the subjective concept of "self".

Grant Morrison describes its origins as follows: "The word 'BARBELiTH' is derived from a dream I had when I was about 20 or 21 and coincided with my first structured 'magical' experiences and a minor nervous breakdown (in the dream, BARBELiTH was the name of some higher dimension or alternate reality)." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barbelith

So it's unclear what all of these things add up to. Whether it might be the Duffer Brothers trolling fans, paying homage to Barb by continuing to acknowledge her both in plot and in subtext, or if the Barbelith is pointing to some kind revenge story for a "mutated" monster-Barb (thinking it could also play on a Hell allegory to Lilith) or of Barb's consciousness is preserved in the Upside Down somehow????


Some additional info on the original intent of the character Bob, and the changes made, have come to light through interviews with The Duffer Brothers. I'm adding this on, because their reason for the change also includes the purpose of Bob, as it relates to Joyce, by siting that his death is a motivator for her to now avenge him--solidifying my suggestion that Joyce is then in parallel to Nancy, and thus Bob is in parallel to Barb.

“That was never on the table. We had talked about the death of some major characters, that may or may not happen in the future near or far. But that was never part of the discussion for Season 2. The death of Bob was initially much earlier. In fact, in an early outline, Evil Will kill him in like Episode 3.”

“We wanted to keep him alive longer, and then use his death as Joyce’s engine,” Levy said. “The avenging of that would become Joyce’s engine for the finale.”

http://collider.com/stranger-things-2-bob-death-original-version-will/#images

  • "So in theory, should Dr. Brenner still be alive, the Hawkins Lab, now under investigation, may remove Owens and reinstate Brenner, seeing Owens as a bigger screw-up." I really don't see that happening. Brenner really screwed up. Not only did his program get out of control - but he had no trouble risking essentially everyone's safety just to keep his program going without interruption. There's no evidence that they were still experimenting after Brenner left; all we know is they were doing damage control. Also the military police seemed to be closing Hawkins Lab at the end. – JMac Oct 31 '17 at 13:20
  • I'm talking about Lab-politics, not outside the lab ethics. The Lab was able to conceal Brenner's actions from the public- - and instead, removed him to let Owen's take his spot, but the nicer scientist is the one that get exploited, not the bad one--he's now a potential fall guy. The fact that we got a juxtaposing scientist is pointing to a hierarchy of scientist and politics of the Lab--plus we got a pretty solid lead in from 8 that Brenner may not dead in episode 7. – Darth Locke Oct 31 '17 at 13:25
  • Also, who says they have one lab or that they wouldn't try and make a make-shift one? – Darth Locke Oct 31 '17 at 13:29
  • 1
    I feel like he was removed once it became clear to other government agencies that he had essentially released a human weapon and a monster. Politics or not, he did a shitty job and I can't see how they would want him back. If he had kept the situation contained it would be different. Even Owen's "mistakes" were really just him doing whatever he could to stop the mind-flayer, not let Will die and deal with the Eleven situation. Plus he managed to get that birth certificate after all this mess, so I imagine his actions were appreciated to some extent by the government. – JMac Oct 31 '17 at 13:31
  • 1
    If it isn't an answer, then why is it an answer? – Worse_Username Oct 31 '17 at 14:04

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .