We see Herr Starr is on a date in Preacher season 2. His date, Sophie (Teri Wyble), is regaling him with a story of how she found meaning in her life. Starr is bored and asks Sophie to remove her top.
Then, he asks her to take the stick of butter on the dinner table and place said butter under her chin. However, before the situation could escalate any further, Starr is informed of the situation with Jesse and his failed capture.
Thus, he dismisses himself from the date and leaves a befuddled Sophie with the butter still under her chin, shirtless in an empty restaurant.
What was he about to do? What was his point in asking her to do so?