2

When Elrond gives Aragorn Anduril, he advises Aragorn to summon the Army of the Dead. As Elrond convinces Aragorn:

You're outnumbered Aragorn. You need more men.

Aragorn agrees with Elrond. When Aragorn came out to the camp with his horse, Brego, Gimli interrupts him. Aragorn says to Gimli to stay, but the dwarf refused. But Legolas contradicts Aragorn. Aragorn agrees that Gimli and Legolas can join him on the Paths of the Dead. When the three travellers are on their horses, the Rohirrim Soldiers are wondering "Why are they leaving at the eve of Battle?" Gamling thinks that they leave because there is no hope. Theoden disagrees with him by replying "He leaves, because he must". So why didn't Aragorn tell Theoden where are they going?

  • 2
    You can argue the same about Gandalf in TTT. "Look towards the East on the 5th day" (or whatever it was), as opposed to "I'm bringing Eomer and his men back; give me 5 days." Artistic license, I guess? – Flater Jul 19 '17 at 18:49
1

He did

...at least in the books.

Aragorn was silent for a moment. ‘Three days,’ he murmured, ‘and the muster of Rohan will only be begun. But I see that it cannot now be hastened.’ He looked up, and it seemed that he had made some decision; his face was less troubled. ‘Then, by your leave, lord, I must take new counsel for myself and my kindred. We must ride our own road, and no longer in secret. For me the time of stealth has passed. I will ride east by the swiftest way, and I will take the Paths of the Dead.

‘The Paths of the Dead!’ said Théoden, and trembled. ‘Why do you speak of them?’ Éomer turned and gazed at Aragorn, and it seemed to Merry that the faces of the Riders that sat within hearing turned pale at the words. ‘If there be in truth such paths,’ said Théoden, ‘their gate is in Dunharrow; but no living man may pass it.’

...

‘You will do as you will, my lord Aragorn,’ said Théoden. ‘It is your doom, maybe, to tread strange paths that others dare not. This parting grieves me, and my strength is lessened by it; but now I must take the mountain-roads and delay no longer. Farewell!’

Return of the King - Passing of the Grey Company

The visit from Elrond in the movie is a creation by Peter Jackson. In the books, Aragorn is visited by Elrond's son, Elrohir who brings him a message from Elrond.

‘I bring word to you from my father: The days are short. If thou art in haste, remember the Paths of the Dead.

In fact, Aragorn was already carrying Anduril in the books...so it seems the scene was to have Elrond at least partially involved and have another refernce to Arwen in the movie.

Any conversation between Aragorn and Theoden therefore, took place, off-screen...or Jackson just left it out entirely.

  • In the books,he told theoden. But in the movies he didn't tell him – The Witch King of Angmar Jul 19 '17 at 20:44
  • 1
    Which is what I mentioned...we don't see him tell Theoden...but that doesn't mean he didn't. There's quite a lot that Jackson left out. – Paulie_D Jul 19 '17 at 20:50
  • Why did Jackson changed the scene – The Witch King of Angmar Jul 20 '17 at 7:17
  • 1
    That's a different question. What extra went into the movie and what was left out could fill a book by itself. – Paulie_D Jul 20 '17 at 9:06

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .