2

American Beauty ended with several juxtapositions, which begs the question, whether it was a happy ending or a sad ending. Every viewer was left wondering if there had been a resolution to a conflict, or the rise of more conflicts. Allow me to break this down for you.

Happy Ending - Lester Burnham dies, and in his last moments he is rather relieved to know that his daughter and his wife are finally happy now, after a prolonged period of his inability to communicate with them. He finally gets to be happy himself, freeing himself of all forms of anxieties, sexual repressions and so forth. Ricky even embraces the moments after his death, seeing the unforgettable smile on Lester's face.

Sad Ending - Some important characters are extremely unhappy, if not utterly traumatized. Carolyn screams in agony, knowing that she has screwed up badly and has lost her entire life. Ricky's dad has returned to a state of homosexual repression. Janie is probably unable to head for NY with Ricky, because of this incident. Angela has lost the only man she fell in love with.

Now, my question is - What did the film want us to feel, or take in. Did it intend a happy ending or a sad ending?

closed as primarily opinion-based by mattiav27, A J, Panther, John, Ankit Sharma Jul 15 '17 at 16:41

Many good questions generate some degree of opinion based on expert experience, but answers to this question will tend to be almost entirely based on opinions, rather than facts, references, or specific expertise. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 7
    This is primarily opinion based question and will beg similar answers. There cannot be definitive one intention for a film - happy or sad. The message does not simply depend on directors intention, but also how audience perceives it. As you pointed out, this movie has sad/happy moments. How can the movie then have one underlying emotion. And most importantly "happy and/or sad" are perceptible, not written on stone (read script). – Paharet Jul 15 '17 at 7:07

Browse other questions tagged .