21

In Passengers, there is a scene where Arthur tells Aurora that Jim couldn't wait to wake her up from hibernation. But Jim specifically tells Arthur, an android, to not tell Aurora. Why does Arthur leak Jim's secret even though Arthur insists he is a gentleman android and he wouldn't tell her?

  • ... What, precisely, is "gentlemanly" about not telling an innocent woman that the person courting her is responsible for her current predicament and woke her out of cryosleep - essentially kidnapping her - out of obsession? – Shadur Mar 29 '17 at 8:03
  • 4
    ...Shadur you are off down your own rabbit hole. The events you refer to are the primary thrust of the plot. If Jim didn't do what he did the film would basically be Cast Away in space and then the ship gets obliterated. Also, there is 0 evidence to suggest that an android would be programmed with your version of 'innocence, kidnap or obsession'. – Venture2099 Mar 29 '17 at 8:29
46

Jim had previously instructed Arthur to keep it secret that he had purposefully woken Aurora up.

Arthur complied with this request.

Many months later, as Jim was preparing to propose to Aurora he made a throwaway comment about his relationship with Aurora:

Aurora: No secrets between me and Jim
Arthur: Is that so?
Jim: You heard the lady

A human would interpret this line with particular boundaries not a definite statement. You can see the direction of the film noticeably frames Arthur's reaction as one of surprise and understanding. The audience can guess what is about to unfold.

As an Android, Arthur took Jim's comment literally, not figuratively. This new information overrides the previous instruction and so Arthur casually mentioned that Jim woke Aurora up on purpose using the line

Jim was so looking forward to meeting you

This sequence of events moves the film into it's Second Act creating the conflict between Jim and Aurora that must be overcome.

13

Because Arthur "thought" she already knows it. This is a part of dialogue that happened before Aurora found out the truth.

Aurora: Anyway, there is no secrets between me and Jim.

Arthur: Is that so? (looking at Jim)

Jim: You heard the lady.

Here is a link to video

3

She tells Arthur that Jim and herself do not have any secrets between each other. As a gentleman I believe Arthur felt the need to be as such by revealing the truth to Aurora.

  • 1
    It was actually Jim that said there were no secrets between them. – sirjonsnow Mar 28 '17 at 12:09
  • 2
    It was't. It was Aurora. I thought it was Jim as well until I rewatched the clip. – Venture2099 Mar 28 '17 at 13:14
  • 9
    @Venture2099 But Jim confirms it, which is the important thing. Even an android would realise that Aurora might think there's no secrets between them even if Jim is keeping secrets from her. – Rand al'Thor Mar 28 '17 at 13:21
  • 4
    While you're correct that Aurora mentions there are no secrets, you're incorrect that Arthur mentions Jim's anticipation out of a gentlemanly need to clear the air of such a secret. As the other answers show, he misinterpreted Jim's confirmation about the lack of secrets as tacit confirmation that his previous condition of not mentioning the secret had been met (re: Jim saying "don't tell Aurora; it's a secret. Let me tell her.") – TylerH Mar 28 '17 at 16:29
-1

When Jim told Arthur about his secret, Arthur appears to be in perfect health. Arthur told Aurora what Jim did to her pod because might be suffering from some malfunctions (short circuiting) after the meteor strike. And he might also be suffering from memory loss. If you listen closely you could hear some things inside of Arthur that sound like clicking and whirring.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .