In 2000s (it aired in America definitely before 2009, when I moved abroad) I was watching a very well made movie on cable. I was in the United States, but it was a German movie, so it 'made it over here.'
To the best of my memory, it takes place in a rural / forested setting, and two men are tormenting a married couple, tying them up, etc.
There is at least one moment of 'fourth wall' where the couple escapes and one of the men quickly says - hold on - and rewinds the scene and catches them.
The cinematography was clean and bright and there were a lot of daytime scenes. It wasn't artsy-weird, but it was independent-foreign thriller. I'm sorry I can't elaborate; due to schedule I only saw the bulk of the 'middle' of the movie. I'd love to watch the whole thing.
EDIT: Just checked the guidelines, I'll try to add more information (below).
Descriptions of any characters or locations - Caucasion, German, mid-20s in a Forest area in summer-ish time; the abusers a little bit like college-style punks
Whether it was animated or not - Not animated