9

In Person of Interest season 1 episode 20 "Matsya Nyay", Kara gives a bad tip to Mark Snow to lure Mark and Tyrell to a hotel. There she kills Tyrell and kidnaps Agent Snow. This is a pre-planned murder of Tyrell, so why didn't Machine warn Finch?

Does the Machine only give the SSN of people not related to terrorism or fighting against it? All CIA agents are supposed to fight terrorism, so they are relevant players.

P.S. This example is from a single episode, however throughout the series the Machine never shares SSNs for CIA agents and other players.

|improve this question
  • 1
    I have a theory for this particular case, but if you want to get a more general answer, please add a few more examples. – Vedran Šego Dec 4 '16 at 14:35
  • @VedranŠego Only concrete example I can think of this. Rest is I feel its not worth sharing as they may be unplanned attempts . So you can answer for this case only too. We will see if someone come up for more general answer – Panther Dec 4 '16 at 15:02
7

The Machine is not omnipotent. It observes people and communications, draws connections, and makes conclusions. Now, in this case, that probably couldn't have happened:

  1. There was no communication to observe, since Kara was working alone, and had no need to communicate her plan and intentions.Luckily for her, POI is not a soap opera where they talk to themselves out loud. ;-)

  2. Being an ex CIA operative for covert operations, believed to be dead and thus hiding from that same CIA, it's safe to assume that she went to great lengths to avoid the surveillance, and that she was capable of pulling it off.

In other words, there was nothing from which the Machine could have detected her intentions.

|improve this answer
2

Vedran Šego's answer more or less covers the specific example in the question, although I feel it's worth adding:

Since Kara is working for Decima who are aware of The Machine it's likely that they will have advised/assisted her in taking extra countermeasures so as not to be spotted

For the more general question

Does the Machine only give the SSN of people not related to terrorism or fighting against it? All CIA agents are supposed to fight terrorism, so they are relevant players.

The machine divides people/threats between those that affect national security (deemed "Relevant") and those that don't ("Irrelevant") and it is the "Irrelevant" numbers that get sent to Finch and at the time of Matsya Nyaya

the "Relevant" numbers are being sent to the ISA personnel operating under the auspices of the "Northern Lights" project.

The only times The Machine sends "Relevant" numbers to Finch & Co. is generally when something breaks down in the arrangement with the govt. e.g:

When "Northern Lights" is shutdown in the wake of the Vigilance leaks The Machine redirects the "Relevant" numbers to "Tertiary Operations" a.k.a Root

and

When Samaritan decides not to act on the threat to POTUS in Synecdoche The Machine sends the designation for Marine One to Reese to get Team Machine to step in (and Reese's number to the Harper-Durban-Pierce team in order to provide the primary team with an exit)

There's also evidence that the Machine can exercise a certain amount of discretion when it comes to the protocols as well since it could also be argued that

Shaw was a "Relevant" number in the season two episode Relevance, she was after all potentially a threat to national security and was certainly a threat to the "Northern Lights" program itself. The Machine however chose to send her number to Finch for them to save (and to recruit her for Team Machine as is essentially confirmed by the Machine in return 0; when she is talking to Shaw)

and where The Machine has realised that the government/ISA themselves are causing the "Relevant" threat such as:

In the season 3 episode 4C the ISA have sent a team to kill Owen Matthews

|improve this answer

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .