4

In the early episode of season 2 of Lost, tracking the survivors of the tail section, it is repeatedly noted that there is one bullet in the gun Ana Lucia takes from Sawyer.

However, she then goes on to shoot Shannon, after which she fires a warning shot to silence Michael and Jin, then continues threatening the others with it as though she has yet more bullets to use.

What gives?

Edit: I noticed she has two guns, actually. I must have missed something. Where did each gun respectively come from?

6

Answer: It doesn't, there are two guns. Ana Lucia has a Beretta 92FS with one bullet which is used when she kills Shannon and the gun she uses later was a Glock obtained from Sayid in the ensuing chaos and fighting.


Long version with evidence:

A transcript of Collision S02E08 explains that this is indeed what has happened.

[Sayid pulls out his gun and goes after Ana.]

MICHAEL: Sayid! Sayid, no!

[Eko tackles Sayid and they fight. Ana cold-cocks Sayid, and grabs the gun.]

MICHAEL: Hey, hey!

ANA LUCIA: [pointing the gun at Michael] Don't move! Nobody move!

Also you can reference the different guns and who had them at www.imfdb.org

Breakdown of events:

1. Beretta has been fully fired

Ana Lucia shoots Shannon with the one bullet from the Beretta 92FS that she stole from Sawyer. Note in the image that she is holding a Beretta which is fully discharged as the chamber is open.

enter image description here

2. Sayid has a Glock and loses it in a fight with Mr Eko

After this Sayid pulls out his own gun and charges Ana Lucia, only to be attacked by Mr Eko, causing him to drop the gun. Sayid and Mr Eko proceed to fight over Sayid's gun which from what I can tell is a Glock 17 or 19 and not the Beretta.

enter image description here

enter image description here

3. Ana Lucia now has the loaded Glock from Sayid

Ana Lucia then joins the fight and takes out Sayid and grabs the Glock, which is likely fully loaded or at least has more than one bullet, and this is the gun that she now uses to threathen the others and fire warning shots with.

enter image description here

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .