2

In A Walk to Remember, there is a scene where Landon asks Jamie to look at a star in her telescope, then reveals that he named it after her.

Landon: Can you find this star right here?

Jamie: Sure. [She looks at the map and adjusts the telescope and finds it pretty quickly] So, why am I looking for this star?

Landon: Because I had it named after you. [Shows a rolled up piece of paper] See? It's official. It's from the International Star Registry. [Jamie comes over and excitedly looks at it]

Jamie: It's wonderful. [whispers] I love you.

As he says, it's from the International Star Registry, which despite what Landon says, is not official at all. But since the ISR has been around from 1979, wouldn't the stars that are easily seen with an amateur telescope have been given names ages ago (or even given official names back when telescopes were first used for astronomy)?

In researching this question, I found that the original script had Landon instead say "I know it's not an official designation—" and not mention the ISR. Pity that the final version made him seem like he got duped into thinking that the ISR gave official names to stars.

  • There are a lot of stars that can be seen with a basic telescope. Estimates of how many can be seen by the naked eye in a good location vary but might be as many as 9-10,000. That said, the most difficult to believe part of this is not that the star would be already named - but that it can be found that quickly. – iandotkelly Aug 17 '16 at 15:06
  • 2
    The ISR is sort of like the Continental Kennel Club. They will do whatever you want for $50. I'm fairly certain that they've never told anyone, "Oh, I'm sorry. That star has already been named after someone." – Johnny Bones Aug 17 '16 at 15:12
  • Cue... "Space is big" quote. – Paulie_D Aug 17 '16 at 15:45
  • 1
    Fun question, but barely movie-related. (But no thumbs down from me! I'm just saying it's not much about movies!) – BrettFromLA Aug 17 '16 at 17:01
  • 1
    @Thunderforge It seems more like a question related to ... business? Like the legitimacy of that business, maybe? I think the question is, "What is the business model of International Star Registry? Do they sell the same stars multiple times? Does anyone respect / use the names they have unofficially 'given' to stars?" – BrettFromLA Aug 17 '16 at 22:42

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .