6

In Batman v Superman (Ultimate Edition), the government decides to nuke Superman and Doomsday when Superman lures/takes the fight with Doomsday into space:

enter image description here

enter image description here

The missile separating to signify its entry into space.

So, the nuclear missile hit them when they were in space:

enter image description here

..and it detonated, resulting in Doomsday and Superman falling back to the earth's surface.

enter image description here

Now, according to Nasa, on the effects of nuclear weapons in space:

If a nuclear weapon is exploded in a vacuum, i.e, in space, the complexion of weapon effects changes drastically:

First, in the absence of an atmosphere, the blast disappears completely.

Second, thermal radiation, as usually defined, also disappears. There is no longer any air for the blast wave to heat and much higher frequency radiation is emitted from the weapon itself.

In the movie, after when they are hit by the nuclear missile, the Government people manning the nuclear launch mission even talk of "re-entry", confirming that the missile hit Superman and Doomsday out of earth's atmosphere. Also, we don't see the usual blast wave that results when a nuclear explosion detonates, which is when the air around it is rapidly displaced by the explosion.

enter image description here Superman after the nuclear hit. Note the particles around him are not moving, meaning they are in a vacuum, hence confirming that they are really in space.

My Question: How is it possible that the bomb detonated in space when there is no air. And how did Doomsday absorb any energy when according to science, there is no thermal energy released when a bomb detonates in space?

7

If the heat is generated by the reaction, and there is no surrounding air to heat up, the heat does not "disappear" - energy and matter can't be created or destroyed. That heat has to go somewhere. The bomb, itself, is made of matter, so would that matter, superheated, disburse? It wouldn't spread like it would in the atmosphere of earth, but the heat would remain undimished/diluted in the bomb materials that get sent out. Also, how does heat get to us from the sun? Emitted as light, not visible, but infra-red radiation, heat can be sent without matter acting as the vessel.

Regardless, how the heat and energy is distributed after the explosion does not prevent the explosion from happening in the first place, since we're not talking about a combustion reaction that would require air/oxygen, but, rather, a nuclear fission reaction, or a fusion one, depending on the bomb type.

Also, were they truly far enough out in space that they were in an airless vacuum? From your post -

resulting in Doomsday and Superman falling back to the earth's surface

How is this possible? Clearly, they must be close enough to the Earth that its gravity can recapture them and pull them back to the planet. If they can be pulled back to Earth, that means there is enough gravity that they are probably still within an area where atmosphere is still retained by gravity. It is very, very thin and sparse, but some atmosphere probably still exists, given the scenario you laid out.

The troposphere, where 80% of our atmosphere is concentrated, goes up to about 7 miles above the earth. The stratosphere, the next layer, that has almost all the rest, goes to 30 miles, and it's too thin there to support winged flight, etc. For all intents and practical purposes, from our perspective, one might think of that as being it for the "working" atmosphere. However, while incredibly thin and sparse, there are more layers to the atmosphere, with the exosphere ending at about 300 miles out. I think most people traveling that far out would think of it as space, even though it's actually still within our atmosphere, along with very, very, very thin air.

  • I would argue that the force from the explosion is what catapulted Superman back to earth, but nevertheless, this answer makes much sense. Thank you. – kelvinelove Sep 29 '17 at 8:47
7

Frank Heile, PhD in physics, answers on Quora:

Nuclear bombs use nuclear reactions, so no oxygen is required. The nuclear bomb is triggered by conventional explosives, be even they will work in space since they are self contained and need no oxygen from an atmosphere.

You might also ask yourself, based on the logic that space explosions require oxygen then how do stars exist? How do super novas occur? Answer: they don't require oxygen. That is only one type of combustion. There are many different forms of combustion that do not require oxygen.

The US has actually tested nuclear space explosions during the Cold War.

In fairness, you are right that the exact explosion might not occur as it did in the movie and that was likely highly exaggerated, but that doesn't change the fact that a nuclear explosion is perfectly capable of being detonated without oxygen.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .