Physical pain is a common motif throughout Fight Club. The members of Fight Club and Tyler all revel in what most people try to avoid. They fight until they have serious injuries that require them to go to the hospital. There's also a chemical burn that each member gets. Getting the chemical burn is an extremely painful process and is almost like a rite of passage into the club. What is the significance/meaning of pain in the movie Fight Club?
-
5There's this line "self-improval is masturbation, but self-destruction..." (is freedom? Or something like that?), which might give some hints at decyphering the Flight Club's philosophy.– Napoleon WilsonCommented Jul 1, 2016 at 14:52
-
Could you explain that philosophy? Is it related to another quote in Fight Club, "Loosing all hope was freedom"? Also, this is not directly related to Fight Club, but since I see you're an expert at film analysis, do you think it's better for people to figure out the themes of films rather than ask others for help?– MoversCommented Jul 1, 2016 at 16:37
-
Don't get me wrong, this is a very interesting question and you did good to ask it here. I was just trying to give some hints at constructing an answer (that I myself am not really sure about either yet). I do not think people shouldn't ask their analysis questions here, since afterall that's what this site is about. It can't hurt to get people's (hopefully reasonably explained) input on a movie's themes, even if you still make your own thoughts about it. Analysis of a movie's themes is one of the primary purposes of this site. (By the way, I'm by far no expert in film analysis. ;-))– Napoleon WilsonCommented Jul 1, 2016 at 16:43
-
2@cde I must have missed it. Could you point out which scene?– MoversCommented Jul 1, 2016 at 18:09
-
1Don't forget the book the film is based on.– cdeCommented Jul 1, 2016 at 20:25
|
Show 11 more comments
3 Answers
One thing about physical pain is that unambiguous with a clear relationship between cause and effect.
While emotional pain can be every bit as intense the cause may be a bit more complex and can be related to attitude and context. Indeed you may not fully understand the root cause of emotional pain.
This may also be related to having control over ones life and emotional state. In fight club the pain is the result of a voluntary decision and something you choose to take on, similarly the 'fight' aspect means that you are in a position to dish out pain directly and immediately to the person who is casuing it to you.
This film is often interpreted as a critique of modern life, in which an individual might suffer pain, stress and anxiety from sources which are both ambiguous and remote. For example if you are worried about money there is often no one single root cause that you can deal with....maybe you are bad with money, maybe you don't have a good enough job maybe it's 'the system'.
But of somebody is punching you the source of the pain is clear and it is equally clear what you need to do about it. this is something which humans arer psychologically very well equipped to deal with. You punch back, submit or run away...simple.
Equally if you are fighting in a system of rules where you choose to fight and you fight just for the sake of it then once the fight of fished that's it, you've survived and you move on with the satisfaction that you have achieved something.
Fight Club is a very complex film that has a lot of references and interpretations, so the physical pain may have various meanings in different scenes or contexts. That said my opinion is the physical pain means the only thing that is real for the main character, therefore is the only thing of value in his meaningless and materialist life. When he feels pain he stops evading and focuses in the only thing that is real.
-
But why is pain the only real emotion? Isn't sadness also an emotion shown in the film?– MoversCommented Jul 2, 2016 at 4:28
-
I'm not talking about emotional pain, but physical (Not sure if this counts as an emotion). Fight Club gets centered in other set of emotions, like anger and abandonment. These set of emotions plus the insomnia SPOILER splits the narrator personalities, one who copes with it (Tyler) and one that doesn't (the Narrator). In the end, sadness is a real emotion but in the movie is not as important as pain which is the way all members of the fight club can identify no matter the emotion they feel. This is of course an opinion, I read the book, saw the movie and this is my the conclusion Commented Jul 3, 2016 at 9:51
-
@PabloRiutort please put some evidences in your answer. Commented Sep 30, 2016 at 6:12
In my opinion, the physical pain is being used as a metaphor for the struggle people face in general in their lives. It shows that people need to go out and attack their problems rather than take a shortcut to solve it or pass it.
