5

In one of the therapy sessions, Will and Sean do not speak to each other. Professor Lambeau asks Sean why he didn't say anything and Sean replies by saying that Will is the one who needs to speak first. I do not understand why Will needed to speak first. Is this something related to psychology (the actual treatment) or does this have some underlining symbolic meaning (literary).

  • 3
    I'm almost positive it will be related to psychology (IANAP). There's definitely an aspect of therapy where the patient must be open to it and willing to participate. If Sean spoke first, then he would be validating Will's silence and basically allowing Will to opt-out of participating in the therapy. – Todd Wilcox Jun 28 '16 at 13:12
  • I always interpreted that it was there to show how good Sean is at reading people. He understands that in order for any real treatment to take place, Will needs to be the one to initiate conversation because it shows that he is starting to open up. If Sean simply started asking questions, Will would remain closed and they would never get anywhere. – sanpaco Oct 28 '16 at 4:03
5

Here's the actual script from the meeting you refer to:

INT. HALLWAY -- LATER

Lambeau and Sean walk down the hallway after the session.
                    LAMBEAU
       What do you mean "he didn't talk?"
       You sat there for an hour?

                    SEAN
       No, he just sat there and counted the
       seconds until the session was over.
       It was pretty impressive, actually.

                    LAMBEAU
       Why would he do that?

                    SEAN
       To show me he doesn't have to talk to
       me if he doesn't want to.

                    LAMBEAU
       Oh, what is this? Some kind of staring
       contest between two kids from the "old
       neighborhood?"

                    SEAN
       I won't talk first.

This is actually, I believe, the 3rd session. The first one, Will comments about the painting and we find out about Sean's wife. The second one, Will and Sean go to the park and Sean basically calls Will out on his M.O.. That meeting ends with this monologue:

                    SEAN 
       Yet you presume to know so much about 
       me because of a painting you saw. You 
       must know everything about me. You're 
       an orphan, right?

Will nods quietly.

                    SEAN (cont'd)
       Do you think I would presume to know
       the first thing about who you are
       because I read "Oliver Twist?" And I
       don't buy the argument that you don't
       want to be here, because I think you
       like all the attention you're getting.
       Personally, I don't care. There's
       nothing you can tell me that I can't
       read somewhere else. Unless we talk
       about your life. But you won't do
       that. Maybe you're afraid of what
       you might say.

Sean stands,

                    SEAN (cont'd)
       It's up to you.

And walks away.

During the 3rd meeting, Sean simply waits him out. Will has to be the one to initiate conversation, Sean already put the ball in his court.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .