8

After the bullet accident in X Men First Class, Charles Xavier (Prof. X) was only able to walk if he injected the serum that Beast created:

No power walking Prof. X in Days of Future Past (Days of Future Past)

This serum blocks his mind powers, but we can see there are at least 2 occasions where he can both walk and use his powers:

Prof. X with powers walking (X-men 3)

First time Prof. X meets Jean

Prof. X with powers walking (Wolverine)

Prof. X rescues mutants from Stryker's lab

Was there a new serum developed that I am not aware of or is there another explanation?

6

Ignoring that these are plot holes born from decades of films, there is two possible explanations.

  1. Xavier isn't really there. Xavier, the most powerful telepath in the world, has been shown to (in comics and cartoons):

    • Make people see things. He is simply projecting his image into people's minds, like he does his voice at various points.
    • Use Astral projection, projecting his mind or soul (or both) into the Astral and Physical worlds.

    Either way, he would be back in the mansion, in Cerebro, still in a wheelchair.

  2. In the original timeline where mystique kills Trask in Paris, Xavier and Beast continue to improve the serum until he can walk and use his powers, but either:

    • Decide that the serum isn't good for mutant-kind, as he does the "cure" in X3.
    • They build an immunity to it, so it no longer works by 1999 (X1).
    • Run out, since it is based on Mystique blood which they don't have access to anymore.

As we know in DOFP, Xavier is going through a emotional and mental crisis, that dictates his actions in shunning his mutant powers. Without a meddling time traveler, he would have continued to have this issues, and things like pretending to walk via mental projections would be one possibility. Or the continued use of the serum another. Until he eventually resolves them internally. Xavier is just like any person, he has to deal with issues over time, and matures emotionally or changes his world point of view. By X1, he no longer feels the need to hide his disability that's connected to his mutant powers.

Same reason he doesn't wear a wig by that time. He's bald because of his powers.

Hank

Keep in mind that Hank has made his serum just enough to keep only the physical part of his Blue mutation away, and can hulk out if needed. Add a few years of tweaking, it's plausible that he was able to give Xavier a serum that allowed some telepathy without affecting his legs. The serum could be temporarily used as needed. Maybe Xavier spent most of the time in the wheelchair unless he needed to go out to meet new mutants.

This would also explain why Hank, having furred out in First Class, looked human in X2. He continued to use the serum as needed even into the 2000s, until X3, where he no longer uses it.

Update:

In DOFP, Xavier does exactly this. He projects and image of himself, standing, into Mystique mind at the end. We see the image fade in and then fade out. At this point in the film, Charles has stopped taking the serum and was in a wheel chair again. Explicit example of image projection.

  • I kind of relate more to your 2nd point and your final paragraph, a temporary use of a new and enhanced serum seems a plausible explanation. The 1st point though, mental projection possibility, fails when he opens that fence with his own hands. In any case, it seems rather elaborate that he would be creating an illusion to Magneto or to whomever was watching so he could pretend he was there with him. – Armfoot Jun 5 '16 at 22:53
3

The answer is, neither of those latter two things ever happened, thanks to Days of Future Past removing those two movies from the continuity.


One of the major plot elements in Days of Future Past is that Wolverine changed the timeline, thus altering everything that happened from 1973 forward. The produces of the X-Men series have openly admitted this, both in-universe and out-of-universe.

Specifically, Days of Future Past completely nullified the events of X-Men Origins: Wolverine and X-Men 3: The Last Stand. Anything you saw happen in those two movies, you can pretend did not happen.

The two scenes you cited are, in fact, two of the scenes we know for a fact cannot possibly have happened.

We know from X-Men: Apocalypse that Jean came to Xavier's school as a much younger woman, seemingly of her own accord, and that Magneto was nowhere to be found when that happened. There also does not appear to be any "block" on her psychic power. So, there's no way that Xavier and Magneto went to her house together to meet her as seen in X-Men 3.

We also saw Stryker's facility where Wolverine was being kept, and there's no indication that he was holding any children hostage. Xavier's school was already well established by the time Wolverine escaped from Stryker, and the entire ending scene (breaking the children out, fighting fake-Deadpool, etc) just never happened.

  • 1
    "neither of those latter two things ever happened, thanks to Days of Future Past (DoFP) removing those two movies from the continuity." It'd be easy to simply explain it like that, but the thing is, future Prof. X knew that he didn't have his powers due to the serum, which means those two scenes in his timeline have happened... Remember Logan's surprise when he saw Jean at the end of the movie? It's just because he remembers to have killed her in X-.men 3 (independently of what producers admitted, DoFP considers both timelines/continuities). – Armfoot Jun 5 '16 at 22:42
  • " Uhmmm...you guys know telepathy is not moving things with your mind right? That’s called telekinesis - Laila Treadwell " – Vishwa Jan 25 '18 at 5:27

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .