8

I've been thinking about something. At the beginning of BTTF 3, when they find Doc's tombstone, it says something about Clara's love... BUT... Clara and Doc would not have met at the time the tombstone was made since she was supposed to go over a cliff and die. They only met because Marty went back to 1885. It was while they were looking for a way to get the Delorean enough room to make it to 88 mph that they saved Clara from going over the cliff. If Marty hadn't gone back to 1885, Doc would not have been anywhere around to save Clara. She would have gone over the cliff and died without them ever meeting. How did her name get on the tombstone?

enter image description here

6

This is covered in the film script;

Mayor: [Coming just inside the door] Excuse me Emmett. You remember last week at the town meeting when you volunteered to meet the new school teacher at the station after she came in?

Doc: Oh yes, quite so.

Mayor: Well, we just got word she's comin' in tomorrow. Here are the details for ya. [He gives Doc a sheet of paper]. Thanks for all your help.

Doc: Walking towards Marty, calling out. Anytime, Hubert!

Mayor: Oh, her name's Miss Clayton. Clara Clayton.

Doc looks up in a state of confusion, putting two and two together. The Mayor leaves before Marty finally speaks.

Marty: Well, Doc, now we know who Clara is.

Doc: [Looking at Marty with a weird grin on his face] Marty. It's impossible. The idea that I could fall in love at first sight? It's romantic nonsense. There's no scientific rationale to that.

The implication is that in the absence of Marty, the Doc would have met Clara at the station preventing her from falling into the canyon. She would have then paid for his tombstone when he got shot.


Obviously this then leads to the secondary question of why the Doc still remembers it as 'Clara Canyon' but there's nothing to say that she couldn't have fallen in at a later date.

  • 1
    Doc remembers it as Clayton Ravine because in the original timeline that didn't include Doc in 1885 -- which would be the one he remembers -- obviously no one volunteered to pick her up, so events played out as they did in the movie except without anyone to save her. – Roger Apr 20 '16 at 20:47
  • @Roger - That may well be true, but he's been in that timeline long enough that the "ripple effect" should have altered his memory. – user7812 Apr 20 '16 at 20:51
  • Clearly, Emmett Brown's a stubborn old coot. :) And, as you say, it's possible in this timeline she still goes in some other time, throws herself over in a fit of grief after Doc's death, etc. – Roger Apr 20 '16 at 21:01
  • @Roger - Possibly. To my mind it seems more likely that she just fell off. We know that she's a klutz who's prone to riding too close to cliff edges... – user7812 Apr 20 '16 at 21:03
4

Doc had agreed to pick Clara up from the train station, so they would have met there had Marty not gone back in time. (One presumes that in this timeline, the ravine was still called Shonash, but it doesn't persist long enough for us to know for certain.)

The only reason she would have gone over the cliff in the first second third place is that Doc wasn't there to pick her up because he was with Marty instead, so Clara decided to find her own way to town.

So:

Timeline A (neither Doc nor Marty): no one picks up Clara, she tries to ride to town, and goes over the cliff.

Timeline B (just Doc): Doc picks Clara up at the station, she doesn't go over the cliff, and they fall in love.

Timeline C (both Doc and Marty): no one picks Clara up, she tries to ride to town, Doc and Marty stop her going over the cliff, and Doc and Clara fall in love.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .