5

If the generals know so much about war, why didn't Ben Kingsley (Mazer Rackham) or Harrison Ford (General Graff) just fight the aliens?

I understand that the younger generation would have a fresh perspective, but I don't understand why they had to go to such lengths to acquire a young brilliant kid, given time constraints, when the generals know just as much.

  • 1
    They made it a point in the movie to say children have better/faster hand/eye coordination than adults, and an attack on that scale was going to need someone with quick reflexes. – Johnny Bones Apr 15 '16 at 17:24
  • 1
    And he has a new and unique and unjaded way of thinking... they want someone who will think outside the box of "training"... which isn't something that an adult can do. – Catija Apr 15 '16 at 18:48
  • Probably for the same reason why video gamers are considered old and on the decline once they hit their early 20s. – PoloHoleSet Dec 13 '17 at 19:22
9

In the source novel, several reasons were given for choosing Ender and his lieutenants at such a young age;

  • Only Ender, as Commander, has sufficient empathy to understand the highly complex flight patterns used by the Buggers (the Formics) but sufficient raw aggression to fight them on their own terms. Note that they still had to trick him. Had he known that he was sending real men to their deaths, he would have balked.

We had to have a commander with so much empathy that he would think like the buggers, understand them and anticipate them. So much compassion that he could win the love of his underlings and work with them like a perfect machine, as perfect as the buggers. But somebody with that much compassion could never be the killer we needed. Could never go into battle willing to win at all costs. If you knew, you couldn't do it. If you were the kind of person who would do it even if you knew, you could never have understood the buggers well enough."

  • Only children have the required hand-eye coordination required to pilot and control the massed fleets.

"And it had to be a child, Ender," said Mazer. "You were faster than me. Better than me. I was too old and cautious. Any decent person who knows what warfare is can never go into battle with a whole heart. But you didn't know. We made sure you didn't know. You were reckless and brilliant and young. It's what you were born for."

  • They've been breeding and selecting children for martial greatness for 50-ish years. Ender might be young but he's described (in all seriousness) as being quite literally one the greatest military minds of all time, regardless of his age

"Does it ever seem to you that these boys aren't children? I look at what they do, the way they talk, and they don't seem like little kids." "They're the most brilliant children in the world, each in his own way." "But shouldn't they still act like children? They aren't normal. They act like history. Napoleon and Wellington. Caesar and Brutus."


As to why they didn't choose Mazer or Graff to lead the Fleet (above and beyond the reasons above) is that Graff is a general who's never fought a single space-battle and Mazer is considered an oddball whose small "strike force" scored an insanely lucky last-ditch blow against the Bugger fleet. He's never been fully trusted by the administration because he's never been able to sufficient explain to those in charge exactly what happened. It's only when Ender arrives that he finally encounters a mind that is on a par with his own:

"The videos of the Second Invasion, when they were destroying our fleets out in the comet shell." He began to call them up and display the buggers' patterns. "Show me the queen's ship." It was subtle. Ender couldn't see it for a long time. The bugger ships kept moving, all of them. There was no obvious flagship, no apparent nerve center. But gradually, as Mazer played the videos over and over again, Ender began to see the way that all the movements focused on, radiated from a center point. The center point shifted, but it was obvious, after he looked long enough, that the eyes of the fleet, the I of the fleet, the perspective from which all decisions were being made, was one particular ship. He pointed it out. "You see it. I see it. That makes two people out of all of those who have seen this video.


In the film they kinda gloss over this, simply noting (in the intro)

The International Fleet decided that the world's smartest children are the planet's best hope. Raised on war games, their decisions are intuitive, decisive, fearless. I am one of those recruits.

1

This may be a very short answer but if you think about this strategically, the buggers (or formics, what ever you want to call them) have already faced both Graff and Rackham before, and would not make the same mistakes twice. so using them would be suicide, but they [graff and rackham] are also on entirely different level of everyone else in their generation, and others from their time may make irrational decisions due to anger, or freeze up when they see the swarms of ships that had once destroyed their homes, so using younger generations, generations that did not see what the buggers did in person, but still needed to be as good as graff and rackham.

  • i think with some editing and a little bit more detail, and maybe some quotes to back this up, and it's got potential to be a really good answer – DForck42 Dec 13 '17 at 17:38
  • @DForck42 I agree – Jonathan Dec 14 '17 at 9:11

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .