11

When the passengers of Con Air arrive at Lerner Airfield serial killer Garland Greene goes on a little scouting trip and finds a little girl playing tea party at a deserted swimming pool. He talks with her a little and ultimately sings with her, and we're likely supposed to believe he killed her the same way he did with the one girl he "drove through three states wearing her head as a hat."

Now this scene always struck me as so surreal and out-of-place that I never was quite sure if she was actually real or not. There are certainly factors speaking for her to be real, primarily the fact that it is a rather straight-to-the-point film in the first place. We also see her at the end when the plane takes off, standing in a little trailer park and waving goodbye (revealing that contrary to our expectation Garland did not kill her). But then again, the fact that Lerner Airfield is supposed to be quite desolate somewhere out in the desert without any people nearby makes it rather unusual to find a little girl strolling around a desolate old swimming pool in the middle of nowhere (and where's that swimming pool even come from?). She also seems to be the only resident of that trailer park at all, if there even was one, since noone else showed up there.

Now it might very well be that I'm imagining way too much here and she was just a girl living there somehow. Or maybe it might even have been deliberately left open for interpretation. But I actually wonder about this scene each and every of the million times I've seen that movie now. So am I actually the only one wondering about that and, even more important, is there any secured information if the little girl Garland meets at Lerner Airfield (and the whole scene afterall) was actually real or just his imagination?

  • 2
    Didn't he leave one of her dolls behind at the end of the movie? – BCdotWEB Mar 11 '16 at 14:20
  • @BCdotWEB Yeah, he is holding on to one of the dolls on the plane. But, there still could be child toys around the trailer park. Considering his mental state, it is a strong possibility that she was imagined. – steelersquirrel Mar 11 '16 at 14:34
  • Most likely just meant to move the story along and offer Garland an opportunity for redemption. After all, why are there air traffic controllers at an abandoned landing strip? – Johnny Bones Mar 11 '16 at 14:37
  • 1
    If it's in the middle of nowhere, maybe some of the people who worked there wanted to live nearby instead of doing massive daily commutes through the desert? They build a few houses and a communal pool, but as the airfield got used less and less the people working there got laid off and moved away, abandoning their homes as nobody wanted to buy them. – Crow T Robot Mar 11 '16 at 15:12
  • 1
    @KristinaLopez - The earlier script (registration required) indicates that he fought his urges and won... "White looks at the girl ... as if he's battling the demons in his mind ... the ones that are saying tear her up and scatter her across the mud". Obviously he's not gonna be hired by any childminding companies any time soon, but the fact that he doesn't act on these urges does show that his therapy and incarceration have helped him to achieved some level of sanity. – user7812 Apr 23 '16 at 13:00
8

Yes, the girl was real. In an earlier version of the script (dated 12/8/95), the version of events, along with Garland White's thought process is delineated much more clearly along with a scene that was deleted from the final draft in which the girl's mother comes looking for her.

Given that the little girl (Debbie) is happily waving at the plane, the scene where her mother finds her was presumably dubbed redundant.

enter image description here

  • 1
    Interesting that his surname was"White" in this script. I wonder why they changed it to "Greene". Well, anyways +1 as usual :) – steelersquirrel Apr 23 '16 at 15:34
  • @steelerfan - That's a good question in its own right. I've no idea why they changed it, nor do any of the three versions of the script give any indication why they made the change. – user7812 Apr 23 '16 at 15:35
  • Hmmm...I guess Garland Greene sounds more like a serial killer ;) – steelersquirrel Apr 23 '16 at 15:37
  • @steelersquirrel Mr. Pink: "Yeah, that's easy for you to say: you're Mr. White. You have a cool-sounding name. Alright look, if it's no big deal to be Mr. Pink, do you wanna trade?" – Ghotir Nov 2 '17 at 20:56
2

The information we were given having seen the doll, the pool, etc seems pretty secure.

I don't think Con Air is a very subtle film overall, and if you read this or look at it's ratings you'll know what I mean. Its main quote is 'put the bunny back in the box' and the bunny itself was thought of by Nic Cage, who then added some very basic significance and meaning to it, later explaining it in an interview.

So I don't think the little girl will have as meaningful a significance as we want her to. She probably mainly adds drama and intensity, something I felt when I saw the movie for the first time. Nothing can really redeem Garland from wearing someone's head as a hat, and, regardless of the intentions of the film crew, I don't think we really forgive him for that overall just for sitting with a girl for an hour without killing her. This said, we haven't really seen much of Garland's cruelty so far, so maybe we can forgive him just a little since the one act we did see him do was not a bad one (compared to all the other criminals who were vicious throughout the film).

The little girl could be there to give us a sense of the madness and confusion of this scene and the criminals. You expect Garland to kill this little girl (or even to try to do so if she is in his imagination), but he doesn't - not in real life, not in his imagination. Cameron Poe shines out more when this has happened, for dealing with these criminals, saving people, not leaving the plane when he had the chance to, and being so honourable in all the time.

When we ask ourselves whether or not the girl is real, we delve into a series of 'Maybe she was just there for the summer?'-type assumptions and questions which are useless and don't help us understand her. If you need to think too much about whether a character was real, often you just need to leave it and consider the importance of the character regardless. Here we know that, whether the girl is real or imagined, Garland didn't kill her and doesn't seem to have tried (I think we would have seen it had he done so) when we expected him to.

So, the girl:

  • Intensifies the scene
  • Shows us the true madness of what is going on, thus emphasising Cameron Poe' regularity and honour as the man who handles it in the end and
  • Possibly redeems Garland a little while showing his insanity and irregularity as a madman

I also think she is real based on what we see, but we couldn't really know.

1

I felt like she was there to give Garland a little bit of humanity to his character instead of just a ruthless killer. I think that her approach to him as friendly and not fearful and the fact that she asked if he was sick and having him admit to her that he was...and after admitting he was sick she still accepted him and wanted to play with him...smiling not shying away from him.....was part of the reason he did not kill her...I didn't find her playing in the pool as odd...its common for poor run down trailer parks to pop up everywhere and they showed signs of life in the trailer park..laundry on clothes lines etc....I actually find it normal for a child who lives in a crowded trailer to seek a solitude area like the abandoned pool to be "her space" to play...if she has brothers and sisters a trailer doesn't offer much privacy....

  • Soooo... Was she real or not? Your analysis may (or may not) be spot on, but doesn't explain whether the girl is actually here. Please edit to clarify, otherwise this isn't really an answer to the question asked. – Jenayah Aug 16 at 19:47
  • @Jenayah It does seem very much to imply she was. The answer explicitly talks about it not being an unusual encounter. – Napoleon Wilson Aug 16 at 19:54
0

she was real i also think she helped the character of Garland Greene she asked if he was sick took medicine he told her there is no medicine for what he has she ask if he wants to sing a song asked if he knew "He's got the whole world in his hands" she did something that was different than anyone else she did not judge him! Adults judged him all the time and this child did not do that! He seemed different after he was with her playing and singing he seemed relaxed calm and happy! As the plane was going down he even was singing that song. It seems she some how got threw to him where no one else did she understood him on a level that she was that showed him it was possible to become a better person!

  • Other than the first three words, does any of this actually answer the question? – Rand al'Thor Mar 17 '17 at 1:03
  • 1
    It's not stated directly in the write-up, unfortunately, but sweetaim is saying that only a real person would change Greene's mental state to one that is so stable. Another possibility is that Greene's own imagination sometimes calms him down. But I would go with sweetaim's interpretation of this since the latter idea is never stated in the movie. – John Mar 17 '17 at 2:57

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .