13

In the pub scene of season 3, episode 2 The Sign Of Three Sherlock says:

I know ash. Don't tell me I don't!

And the guy Sherlock is talking to attempts to punch Sherlock in his face in the very next moment.

Why?

Why would anyone punch someone because of his knowledge of different types of ash?

Could the guy have difficulty hearing anything else and thus misinterpret the whole situation? Could he understand "ash" as "Ash" for Ashley or Ashton?

22

The ash knowledge is a reference to the classic Sherlock Holmes from the novels. The punch is for being drunk and obnoxious.

Spark Notes have an article on classic Sherlock Holmes references, and they have a small section that covers the ash discussion perfectly, so I'll quote it in its entirety:

During a particularly memorable scene in [The Sign of Three], Sherlock declares proudly that he “knows ash!” This references the fact that Holmes has penned a monograph on the subject of tobacco ash, first mentioned in A Study in Scarlet. Holmes uses this skill-set to figure it all out in The Hound of the Baskervilles and The Valley of Fear. This reference might also refer to the real-life Sherlock Holmes fan society The Adventuresses of Sherlock Holmes (ASH for short), a scion of The Baker Street Irregulars, which was founded by female fans of the great detective, since the original Irregulars didn’t originally allow ladies!

Whilst I believe the reference to the real-life fan society is a step too far, the reference to the historic novels is certainly what resonated with me. Whilst their article mentions The Hound of the Baskervilles and The Valley of Fear, Holmes also used his knowledge of ash to solve the crime in The Adventure of the Resident Patient

He also says in the Boscombe Valley Mystery

"I have, as you know, devoted some attention to this, and written a little monograph on the ashes of 140 different varieties of pipe, cigar, and cigarette tobacco."

So, firstly, he clearly knows his ash!

As to why he is hit, it's due to his drunken, obnoxious behaviour. To quote from the script:

NEXT PUB. Sherlock is plastered. In the smoking area outside the pub, he is loudly and drunkenly gesticulating and sounding off to a male customer over the very loud music.

SHERLOCK: I know ash!
(John is sitting at a nearby table, looking fairly legless himself. He covers his face with his hand.)
SHERLOCK: Don’t – Tell – Me – I – Don’t!
(***On each word he pokes the man in the upper chest with one finger, and on the last word he puts his hand on the man’s shoulder and pushes him.* Sighing, John looks up as the man swings a punch at Sherlock’s face. Sherlock sways back – possibly more by luck than judgement – and avoids it.)**
JOHN (jumping up): Oh ...
(Thrown off-balance by his swing, the man stumbles forward and almost falls onto a nearby table. One of his mates helps him up. John grabs Sherlock from behind and pulls him away while Sherlock flails wildly towards the man.)
JOHN: All right, enough! That’s ...
(Grunting with the effort and slurring the rest of his words [possibly saying ‘Come on’], he drags Sherlock a few feet away, supporting most of his weight, before propping him onto his feet.)
JOHN: Stand up straight.
(Sherlock turns round towards him. John points towards the exit to Sherlock’s left.)
JOHN: Yeah.
(Sherlock points back towards the customer.)
SHERLOCK (slurring): Ashtray. I know ashtray.

It's generally not a good idea, late at night, when drunk in a pub, to start poking and pushing an already quite annoyed person!

Therefore, he got punched.

-3

Well technically he says after john pulls hime away "I KNOW ASHTON" however the reason he almost got punched was because he was yelling at the guy and then pushed him.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .