8

In movie Predestination (2014),

a single woman (and man afterwards) repeats the same cycle starting from kidnapping of a baby, falling in love, etc.. and then again starting from beginning.

So, how was the baby born for the first time, and how does it come to know about the predestination?

  • 1
    Nice question. This kind of confusion always happen to me when watching time travel movies. they usually result in plot holes which sometimes, Unfortunately, writers do not care enough to fill. I watched the movie a while a go so I don't remember it well. – onlyforthis Jan 13 '16 at 8:32
  • 2
    Did the cycle start from the baby kidnapping? It might've started from this woman(Jane)meeting a man (herself from the future) and having the baby. Then dropping the baby on the doorstep of the orphanage. Then the baby grows up and happens to be the same girl and experience the same events again. What started what? It's an egg chicken situation. It might be a plot hole as I mentioned. let's wait for answers. – onlyforthis Jan 13 '16 at 8:32
  • @onlyforthis Yep, I too thought the exact same egg chicken thing :) – Snazzy Sanoj Jan 13 '16 at 8:34
  • @onlyforthis Also, the story seemed to me that he(from future) left her, when they were on a date. So, that could have not been a possible start. I'm not sure though. – Snazzy Sanoj Jan 13 '16 at 8:37
  • Can this even be answered beyond speculation or opinion? AFAIK there is no official source telling us how it works, so this question cannot be answered in the way SE understands answers? I would love to write my view of this as an answer, but: It's an opinion, not a fact? – Florian Peschka Jan 13 '16 at 9:50
3

I could not find any official sources on that, but I believe that the question "What started it" might be answered with: The invention of time travel.

Similar to how the time travelers cannot travel further than (what was it, 50? don't quite remember) years ahead/behind point zero (which seems to be a that's just how it is thing in the universe of the movie) I think that this time loop the protagonist is stuck in, is an anomaly (or is it a "nomaly" when inventing time travel? who knows...) that was created at the instant the humans of that universe "broke" physics for the first time.

We cannot find a "true" beginning, because there isn't one. From outside of the loop, the events unfold in a logical manner and all people that were not the protagonist are just passing through the loop unaffected. Even other time travelers might be just fine in the sense that they have travels with escape routes.

It is only this strange instant of the protagonist which is stuck forever in the loop, reliving it over and over again, while all other people pass through it.

At the end of the movie, the handler says:

Understand, you are more than an agent, you are a gift given to the world through a predestination paradox. You are the only one. Free from history, ancestry.

(Emphasis mine)

Which gave me the idea for this theory... But ultimately, we cannot know the answer.

7

There was no "first time". It's a bootstrap paradox in which Jane is his/her own father and mother.

Because time travel is being used, it's perfectly possible for an effect to precede a cause, in this case for the original Jane to have been born before her mother. The whole point of the film is that Jane/John exists within a closed time loop.

The ThisisBarry website offers this attractive diagram to help understand what's going on. Note that the events are presented as circular. You can start at any point and the plotline is essentially identical.

enter image description here

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .