6

I have recently watched Silent Hill again, but I couldn't really understand its ending. Rose and Sharon seem to be forever trapped within the foggy dimension, but neither of them seem to really understand that. They are no longer in Silent Hill, but neither are they in the "real" world. Sharon seems to be possessed, but the ending is very vague about everything. I have read some opinions on IMDb, but neither were truly answering my question, or else I wasn't able to understand them. Are the games vital to the understanding of the movie (I have played none of them)?

What happens to the girls at the end of the movie?

  • Sharon seems different because she's not completely Sharon anymore. Dark Alessa (Alessa's evil side) and Sharon (Alessa's good side) merge after the church massacre. Alessa is, in a sense, reborn whole; only now she finally has the mother she deserves. So Alessa, who created fog world and controls who enters/leaves, isolates both herself and Rose in fog world, presumably to shelter them from the pain and hatred that's inherent in the outside world. Alessa is giving herself the childhood she never had. – b1nary.atr0phy Dec 25 '17 at 7:56
5

Yes, in the movie, they are in different dimensions. When they go back home and Christopher is in the same room, they cannot see each other. Also the color of the scene is different to suggest that (that is the same chair):

enter image description here real dimention

One theory (I cannot find some backup canon sources) states that they stay there because Alessa doesn't want them to leave. I'll add something if I can find some definite answer to this.

  • That's the interpretation I go with as well. The idea is that Alessa and Sharon recombine and become a complete person but because Alessa suffered so much in the real world she would rather stay with her new mom in the world she created and pulled Silent Hill into. Cecil from goodbadflicks has a good video on the movie here: youtu.be/CfEnsMWYisI and he uses interviews and commentaries for research. – Sloloem Nov 17 '15 at 17:01
  • The idea that Alessa doesn't want them to leave isn't exactly a theory. After Rose encounters Dhalia, she tells Rose, "Only the Dark One opens and closes the door to Silent Hill." – b1nary.atr0phy Dec 25 '17 at 4:40
1

As shown in the sequel, they are still trapped in the silent hill dimension because of the cult, which required Sharon (Now called Heather). And it's not any new dimension; they are in the same silent hill dimension.

It's shown in the sequel that Sharon's mother transported her back to the real world through the mirror using an amulet and she herself remains in the silent hill to distract but things doesn't stop there...

0

I do not really think that the video game series is vital to the understanding of the movie Silent Hill.

In fact, concerning the Silent Hill games, there are several of them, but they all deal with different stories.

For instance, the 1st game Silent Hill deals with a guy named Harry Mason who searches his adoptive daughter Cheryl after a car accident, while the game Silent Hill 2 talks about James Sunderland who decides to go to Silent Hill town after receiving a letter from his deceased wife Mary.

However, even though all the games have different stories, they still have common things like:

  • the main characters need to survive against a lot of creepy monsters, in a scary alternate dimension (for information, only some game scenarios occur in the town Silent Hill, but not all of them)

  • the player need to solve crazy puzzles

  • short vision range: sometimes when exploring the games, you have thick snow and / or no light (so, the player need to use a flashlight and BOOH! Here comes a creepy monster ;P )

  • ambiguous endings: according to the paths you followed during the games, you can have a "good", "bad", or "joke" (= crazy funny ending which can include UFOs for example) ending.

When playing a given game, you may find some references to another game, but these do not consist in a essential link to continue your quests and to succeed in the game.

When watching the movie, you notice that the adaptation shares similar stuffs coming from the video game series, but the story remains different.

Considering the end of the movie, I think that they wanted to keep this ambiguous feeling and let the spectators decide what would be the ending. So, it would be up to us to decide what happens: they may be still trapped in this hell dimension, or they might be possessed, or they might be trapped in their mind or some kind of nightmare (I think that in one of the video game, there's an ending where you finally understand that the main character was actually insane or in a coma... I will have to check that.

  • Have you seen the movie? What is your opinion on the ending? – Dragos Sep 10 '12 at 8:57
  • @Dragos: Yes I watched the movie a long time ago ^^. For me the child is still possessed and they're trapped in the alternate dimension lol :D. – Littm Sep 10 '12 at 9:02
  • Are you saying that there can be no explanation, because the team behind it wanted it that way? I was actually hoping for some reasons behind them being trapped there and the possession of the girl. I will keep the question open in order to read other opinions. Thank you! – Dragos Sep 10 '12 at 9:28
  • Too much irreverent explanation. – Ankit Sharma May 17 '14 at 14:01
0

I believe that they're dead and in purgatory. When they're in the church or whatever, Rose screams, "you're all dead, you died in the fire" and it's plausible that Rose died on her way to Silent Hill. The characters can obviously die, which could mean that they passed on to another stage of the afterlife. At the end of the movie, they try to return to their home but can't exactly go home, i.e. return to the real world and the weather is unseasonable, with the snow and fog but the dude at the same house is sunny (as seen above) so they could be dead and in purgatory?

  • 1
    Please see Ankit's answer. It's revealed in the sequel that they never left purgatory, but Rose was able to send Sharon back using the metatron amulet. – DustinDavis Dec 8 '17 at 17:52
0

I think that when the evil of Alessa is moving towards Sharon she manages to get into Sharon the same way she does with Rose. This is partly because they are stuck in the dimension where Silent Hill is a twisted nightmare but also because of the elongated look that both Sharon and Dahlia share. There was something off about that, Dahlia is looking at her as she is identical to Alessa but Sharon has never seen this woman before. The way she was looking at her was off putting which leads me to believe that that is in fact both Alessa and Sharon at this point.

0

Dahlia tells us in the beginning that only the dark one could open and close the doors to Silent Hill. At the end when Bad Alessa was climbing the ladder and Sharon was supposed to keep her eyes closed but opened them they became one again so technically Sharon wasn't there anymore only Alessa remained. She allowed them to leave but not really. They are no longer in Silent Hill but they aren't in the real world either. They are in some foggy dimension instead.

0

I’ve not played the game but most movies don’t follow the source to begin with. It appears everyone is in purgatory, a limbo between heaven and hell. That’s why the road is gone to keep them trapped. Also that’s why they have partial peace and partial hell in their life. They have sanctuary in the church but once the evil got inside they were punished for the evil deeds they committed when they were alive. The mother, daughter, and the officer all lost their lives in the wreck in the beginning in the rain drenched road. That’s why they wake in the fog in the same purgatory.

-1

Do you remember the part where? The mother told her daughter to close your eyes? (At the near end) She did not and she saw the demon girl(?). I think she wasn't supposed to see her then boom, because of that they are trapped.

  • 1
    Any support of you claim? – Ankit Sharma Nov 17 '15 at 10:51

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .