4

In the Lord of the Rings Trilogy (Part 2: The Two Towers), where do the Elves go after the battle in the Helm's deep? The next morning when they (Aragorn and the others) open the gates and charge forward, we do not see any Elves (the ones who were commanded by Haldir). In the movie it's the scene right before when Gandalf shows up with Eomer and the other riders.

2

The Elves at Helm's Deep were a departure from the book version and were added for some reason by Peter Jackson and his team.

Because of this, they would need to play a bigger part in an already pretty expansive story or they would have to be quietly dropped from the plot.

Perhaps they filmed a few scenes either about them getting wiped out or going home, but it seems that they were simply dropped in the hope that nobody would notice.

  • You mention a fair bit about the book, but hero is asking specifically, in the film, why do we not see Elves ride out to meet gandalf. – davidlumix Sep 9 '15 at 10:47
  • 1
    In fairness to myself :), I only refer to the book once to explain why they seem to serve no purpose and then simply vanish: to continue with them would be to continue to depart from a very expansive plot. They have very little time to get through the story despite there being three movies, and so they simply dropped them. I noted in the release version also they dropped other things that were more crucial (like Frodo's oddly magic cloak that used in Movie #3; the one he didn't get from Lorien) – Yorik Sep 9 '15 at 14:25
2

I think we can safely assume that all the Elves died during the fight. They took the full brunt of the Urak-hai army on the ground after the wall was destroyed.

Let's not forget, that their commander (the only Elf who could have issued a retreat) was Haldir - and he died.

The Elves are fiercely well trained and proud fighters, it is no surprise at all that they fought til death, instead of retreating to the keep.

  • davidlumix, i like your assumption (that they all died). BTW, I believe Eomer was not an elf, he is actually kind Theoden's nephew and the elves were led by Haldir (as you correctly said dies during the battle). – hero007 Sep 4 '15 at 14:42
  • @hero007 apologies - that was an error. – davidlumix Sep 4 '15 at 14:43
  • This seems the most likely correct answer and is what I had assumed as well. In the book, just about everyone dies in the battle up until the final ride out so its is fair and safe to assume anyone not alive at that point was killed. In the scene where Haldir is killed, Aragorn issues the order to him to retreat, but before he can pass this order on he gazes around at all his fallen troops and is then killed himself. – sanpaco Dec 8 '15 at 18:20
1

In the book, the elves from Lothlorien were not involved in this battle. A few days after the battle of Helm's Deep, orcs from Dol Guldur swarmed into the forest of Lothlorien in a full-scale assault. They were repulsed by the power of the elves and Galadriel’s ring.

I assume that in the movie, elves who survived the battle of Helm's Deep, immediately returned to Lothlorien to defend their forest.

1

well in the movie i could see some elves running trough this round arch door thing and then towards an entrance so i just assume they left helmsdeep after the battle (Not filmed) to go to valinor or where all the elfs went when they left these middle earth lands. :) but thats how i just like to see the end of the elfs.....

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .