After watching Age of Ultron (in which, ridiculously reduced, Ultron, tasked with saving humanity, decides that to save it, he must destroy it, because it is its own worst threat) I thought of I, Robot (the movie) in which the robot master decided that humans had to be dominated in order to protect them. Now I am looking for other examples of the artificial intelligence deciding that the greatest threat to humanity is humanity.

What is the earliest presentation of something along these lines?

  • 5
    "..what is the earliest presentation of something along these lines?" This is a specific, answerable question, but anything starting with "What are other examples of.." is likely to be closed for asking for 'lists of movies'.. Aug 10, 2015 at 23:18
  • Hmm.... does it have to be artificial intelligence, specifically? Or can a human being decide that earth would be better off without humans, as well? That would definitely push back the timeframe; I'd expect that particular trope to have come up in some nuclear-doomsday-related scenario.
    – DevSolar
    Aug 11, 2015 at 16:15
  • 3
    Probably not the first one, but the 1951 movie "The Day the Earth Stood Still" is one of the most famous early movies that would sort of fit what you're looking for. "An alien lands and tells the people of Earth that they must live peacefully or be destroyed as a danger to other planets." Not sure if it completely fits since it is more about saving OTHER planets from Earthlings, but also kind of about saving Earth from Earthlings. imdb.com/title/tt0043456 Aug 12, 2015 at 22:22
  • Unless you specifically only want the earliest version of this trope in movies or TV, (and even if so,) this question might be better served in the Science Fiction & Fantasy SE. Aug 13, 2015 at 0:59
  • 1
    @MeatTrademark I would prefer it as a trope in a visual medium. If you think I would get another type of answer in SF (text based) I can ask it there as well.
    – rosends
    Aug 13, 2015 at 2:19

1 Answer 1


I think this is probably answerable.

The easiest answer is "Colossus: The Forbin Project" which is a semi-satirical take on the subject (filmed in 1970, based on a contemporary book). A super-computer built in the US to defend against a Soviet attack combines with its Soviet counterpart to dominate all aspects of human behavior. You can watch it on YouTube (with commercials):

This was original enough at the time to impress mainstream critics, even though it was already a hoary concept in genre fiction. It spawned (or at least heralded) numerous other computer-knows-best/computer-controlled-society films like Logan's Run, WarGames and (arguably) Tron and The Matrix.

But I'm never happy with the obvious answer if I haven't really looked back at the catalogue to see where things really started, so let's see where that takes us. I'm using IMDB, YouTube, Ed Naha's Science Fictionary and Michael Weldon's Psychotronic Video Guide as my sources.

Predating robots, "The Golem" (in its many variations) often had a theme of going amok or turning on its creator. Amok robots show up in silents and cartoons in the 10s, 20s and 30s—Mickey Mouse had a run-in with a robot! The (oft filmed) 1920 play "R.U.R." which introduced the word "robot"—and results in humanity being wiped out—was probably the tone-setter, and this tone is what Isaac Asimov ("I, Robot") was reacting to.

N.B.: Asimov is doubtless where you would go to find the purest fictional examples of benevolent-robot-over-man. He was a true believer in eventual robot superiority (see Star Trek: The Motion Picture.) Curiously none of these stories have ever been filmed, as far as I can tell, the irony of which will be apparent shortly.

By the time you get deep into the 30s, machines aren't turning on man so much as man is turning robots into war-machines, like "Loss of Sensation" (USSR) and "Master of the World" (Germany). I think this is because the computer—the "thinking" part of the robot—didn't really exist. (Robots, when they rebelled, essentially became human, and the concept of them having super-brains didn't permeate pop-culture until the '50s.)

I'd be willing to commit to 1951's The Day The Earth Stood Still as the first "live in peace or be destroyed" movie—up until then, aliens were all about conquest of earth. Although, we should give a nod to 1918's Himmelskibet where a journey to Mars, and its pacifist, fruitarian (!) inhabitants, results in a sort-of "mission to earth" without the "or else" of TDTESS.

Himmelskibet on YouTube:

But that doesn't really have the "Man vs. Machine" aspect that Dan asked for. It's really "Man vs. Alien", where the aliens have robots. I think we'll have to look a bit later.

The first inklings of "machine knows best" is perhaps "The Twonky" (1953). A guy's wife buys him a TV and the TV starts to run his life. It's adversarial and the twonky's motives are probably best considered parasitic, but it gets us a bit closer to the goal.

1956 brings us Forbidden Planet, and while we could wildly speculate the extinct Altairians had a computer-controlled society, the more relevant aspect is Robbie the Robot. Robbie—the same character!—would re-appear in 1957, in the odd and obscure film The Invisible Boy, wherein a little boy is controlled by a computer and directed to rebuild a robot (Robbie) that his father has brought back from the future where Forbidden Planet took place! The master computer plans to use Robbie to gain control of the earth. We almost have it, except the super-computer's actions are merely self-preservational and/or conquest.

Now things start to get hairier. The USSR launches Sputnik. SF Anthology series like "The Twilight Zone", "One Step Beyond", "The Unforeseen" and "The Outer Limits" start to proliferate. (There were earlier speculative fiction anthology series as well, like "Lights Out", an episode of which presaged the plot of They Live, but they tended to be more supernatural than science-fiction.)

"The Twilight Zone" has a couple of episodes that tease the Master Computer trope, all dystopic. When Burgess Meredith is declared "obsolete", no computers are involved, but this is clearly a reference to fears regarding automation and totalitarianism. The episode "Uncle Simon" has an inversion of what we're looking for (with a human forced to tend to a robot). "The Brain Center at Whipples" is another typical TZ entry where automation has (inevitably) wicked consequences.

"Outer Limits", of course, has the classic "Demon with a Glass Hand" which would become the lawsuit-winning inspiration for Terminator's Skynet.

1962's The Creation of the Humanoids gives us a world largely run by robots that live side-by-side with humans and try to help them survive (YouTube):

Not quite there, as there is freedom in action, and there's a lot of Blade Runneresque blurring of lines.

The TV Show "Out of this World" has an episode featuring a supercomputer named "Eddie". But he doesn't take things over.

And now we're coming up on Colossus's own time with 1965's Alphaville, which has a computer controlled-society. I don't recall any utopian sentiments being mentioned in its construction; as I recall the computer was built with malice aforethought, but I can't swear to that.

Of course, then you have "Star Trek", with its numerous tales of computer-controlled societies. None of them are Earth societies, and they tend to be primitve ("The Apple") or stupid ("Spock's Brain"). About this time, Dr. Who's WOTAN was going crazy hypnotizing people (a la "The Invisible Boy")!

I think we've come to the end of our journey at this point. "Star Trek" episodes aside, we have (in 1966) what I think is oldest filmed fictional example of the premise, an episode of "Out of the Unknown", which is based on an E.M. Forester story that may be the oldest literary example. It's called "The Machine Stops", and it is about a machine that provides everything people in its underground society needs, as a way to optimally (from its point of view) manage them.

Sadly, the BBC doesn't seem to allow this show to be viewed online, nor do they sell it.

The irony that I mentioned above? Isaac Asimov was the source for six episodes of "Out of the Unknown", but not any that fit the trope we're looking for!

I hope you've found this interesting and/or useful.

  • Wow. Very through. Welcome and +1
    – cde
    Apr 3, 2016 at 5:02
  • 1
    Thanks! I didn't mention it, but the E.M. Forster story is free to read (and not too long) online, for those interested.
    – moviegique
    Apr 4, 2016 at 16:48
  • First video is down now.
    – Ankit Sharma
    Jun 2, 2016 at 6:06
  • The Internet is funky that way. youtube.com/watch?v=Pt_i-aW4s9A has it currently. You actually can't buy it in its widescreen original format, AFAIK, at least not in America.
    – moviegique
    Jun 3, 2016 at 17:07
  • 1
    Is The Creation of the Humanoids based on Jack Williamson's story “With Folded Hands”? Jun 21, 2017 at 8:28

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .