26

Having watched the first 4 episodes, I've noticed something rather peculiar: No one ever acknowledges Mr. Robot, except Elliot. Is there any evidence that Mr. Robot is or isn't just in Elliot's head, similar to

Fight Club?

migrated from scifi.stackexchange.com Jul 29 '15 at 19:52

This question came from our site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts.

  • 2
    No way to know yet, based on what has been exposed to the audience. – wbogacz Jul 29 '15 at 19:55
  • This can't be answered until it is revealed / confirmed in the show, which it hasn't at this time. There are many theories ranging from multiple different people being aspects of Elliot (including Tyrell) and multiple people being aspects of Angela, or even Elliot and Angela both being aspects of each other. – JoshDM Jul 29 '15 at 20:06
22

Mr. Robot is all in Elliot's head. He is, in fact, Elliot's mental construct of a version of his father who had died years ago. Darlene confirms in eps1.8 (episode 9), that Elliot is the one who founded FSociety.

So, in the show, Mr. Robot, we're falling down the rabbit hole that is Elliot's mind. As the unreliable narrator of the show, we experience what Elliot experiences and we follow along with him.

In an article from the Observer:

You knew all along, didn’t you?” Elliott Alderson asked us, his collective imaginary friend, in last night’s episode of Mr. Robot. And the answer, at least on my part, was: “did we?”

I mean, of course it was there all along — Christian Slater’s Mr. Robot is simply Elliot’s own Tyler Durden, a manifestation of his guilt-ridden and damaged mind molded in the image of his father. Of course Mr. Robot isn’t actually Elliot’s long-dead-or-so-we-thought dad, who had somehow been hiding his existence from his own son for 20 years. It was all there, the way Elliott would sink into the background any time Mr. Robot addressed FSociety, the way Mr. Robot would participate in discussions but the other members wouldn’t exactly acknowledge his input. Mr. Robot was always in the backseat of the car, or appearing at just the right moment not to interfere, but to dispense advice. We knew. We knew all along.

As an added note, the piano piece playing at the end of this episode of Mr. Robot is a piano cover of The Pixies' "Where is My Mind", which is the same song playing at the end of Fight Club.

Fight Club version (The Pixies):

Mr. Robot Version (Maxence Cyrin):

-1

As I'm not a scenarist of this show, I can't be sure at 100%. But, if you see s01e07, you see that Mr.Robot is speaking and threatening Romero.

So, I don't think that Mr.Robot is in Elliot's head.

  • 1
    But Mr.Robot could be Elliot. When Elliot is around, we never see Mr.Robot talking to others. In this particular scene, I saw that Mr.Robot smokes a cig like Elliot smoked a joint earlier in the season. – milk2go Aug 11 '15 at 14:59
  • 2
    Yes, maybe. Anyway, we can't know until the end of the season. But, it could be true. I remember the episode 6, when we see Mr.Robot talks to Elliot in the stairs. It's like Mr.Robot is from nowhere ! – Nairolf21 Aug 11 '15 at 18:38
  • 1
    I know it's known now, but I just want to reply to your answer that both Fight Club (Tyler Durden) and Dexter (Dexter imagining Rudy in S5) have been visualized as taking actions, even though it was actually the other guy doing it. So even if Mr Robot threatens Romero, that can be a visualization of Elliot doing it while in the Mr Robot persona. – Flater Oct 30 '15 at 11:17

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .