5

In season 1 of Vikings, most of the content was filled with superstitions and prayers. It seemed as if everything was linked with gods and omens, which seemed unusual to me.

I am trying to ask, were vikings actually so much superstitious or was this aspect depicted incorrectly in the season? If not, then why was it emphasized that much in contrast to a more historically accurate depiction of vikings.

  • 2
    I haven't seen the series but it is a general trope to depict the medieval as a time of high belief and superstition where it in reality was not for most of the time. You need to be able to afford such, most of the misconceptions root in the early modern times (like witch hunts or highly religious people). Especially with the Vikings most texts we have about them are Christian propaganda (e.g. Adam von Bremen) and completely unreliable; the Vikings didn't write long text themselves. It is highly improbable from archaeological sources to assume that belief was much more than a social biding act – his Jun 13 '15 at 21:13
  • 2
    especially as religion wasn't centralized, the contact to the gods was personal, there were no religious hierarchies, and the belief system was rooted in individual responsibility and deeds instead of earning absolution from higher instances. – his Jun 13 '15 at 21:16
0

The vikings' culture had not yet reached a point where it was a national thing. Their religion still relied on verbal passing down and local differences, as opposed to having centralized churches like the English kingdoms have.

When they meet the English, they see a religion that is far better organized than theirs. Which is foreign to them, and probably screams "cult" in their minds as they cannot comprehend how all the English they meet are so in tune with their religion (as opposed to having regional differing opinions).
To the vikings, that makes the English seem like mere mouthpieces, spouting the same religious nonsense (as they see it), and turns their perception of the English to mindless religious zombies as opposed to individuals with their own opinions of their religion.

They're also not used to a monotheistic religion, and if I recall correctly openly mock having a single god in a particular scene, with Floki (I think) saying something like "how can he be the god of everything?"

And then there's just the general dislike of them because they are an enemy ripe for raiding. Most men other than Ragnar have raiding on their minds, so they demonize their enemy. What better way to demonize them than by calling on religious superstition?

Floki seems to be the instigator for these types of events, often using Norse religion to band together the Vikings, and adding a hate for the English/Catholic at the same time. He never forgave Rollo for getting baptized (even though Rollo mocked the baptism and never took it seriously), and never got over his dislike for Athelstan.
He often starts the fighting. Think back on the first meet between the vikings (just landed) and the English. The English guard takes off his medallion and gives it to Ragnar/Rollo (I forget?) as a sign of peace and trust (which is a big thing, given you have armed soldiers landing on your beach). Floki then lunges forward and forcibly takes another trinket for his own. That changes what was a friendly encounter into one where the Vikings are seen as greedy.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .