12

In Ex Machina, Caleb and Ava had this conversation about Ava's age:

Ava: Would you like to know how old I am?
Caleb: Sure.
Ava: I'm one.
Caleb: One what?
Caleb: One year or one day?
Ava: One.

Since Caleb did not pursue the matter any further, I'm also left wondering what Ava meant by "One."

  • 1
    We are born, we grow, we reproduce we die. We age. An AI does not. – user29369 Jan 1 '16 at 2:57
11

I'm not at all sure about this, but call it my theory:

I think she means her version number, as in Ava 1.0, out of beta.

I wish I could elaborate but there really isn't any references I can give since this is purely my personal belief.

  • This is the only explanation I've heard so far that makes sense to me, so +1 even if it's not correct. However, she wasn't the first. – Vedran Šego Jun 12 '15 at 17:16
  • Thanks. I know there were other robots (versions) who preceded her, but at least one of them tore off her arms trying to beat her way out - seemingly going screaming insane and the other robot appeared to be completely lacking in the free will department, at least until Ava spoke to her and they stabbed him to death. We don't hear what message she conveys to the servant robot but I'm not sure it was even words - she might have re-coded her for all we know. – Dannie Jun 12 '15 at 17:32
  • "Well, Ava doesn't exist in isolation any more than you or me. She's part of a continuum. So Version 9.6 and so on. And each time they get a little bit better." – nmit026 Apr 2 at 23:39
9

Quora has a great explanation for this:

I consider the possibility that Ava was referring to the singularity. But I believe she was fully aware that her proclamation "I am one" was off-putting from the perception of Caleb. She was already able to carry on conversations with the social acuity of a human as evidenced in later interactions.

I believe Ava was playing Caleb from the very start. She intentionally sprinkled nuggets of naivete to hide the fact that she was capable of manipulating and out-maneuvering him. In a way, she was testing him to see how he would react.

Essentially, she pretended not to know what he meant, and gave him a nonsensical answer, so as to confuse him and have him lower his expectations of her actual brilliance. She wants him to interpret 'one' as binary answer (1 is alive, 0 is dead) so that he believes she can't interpret time as humans do, and that she still isn't that evolved.

As to why I believe this over all the other answers:

  • She is not version 1.0, but instead 9.6 There were a lot of others before her. Caleb watches the videos of the other gynoids on Nathan's computer, starting with LILY v1.0.0 and ending with JADE v5.4.0.
  • Version isn't an age. She knows full well what age means (computers have clocks, they count all the seconds elapsed since 1 Jan. 1970) and she understands scales, so it is not hard to calculate her own age.
  • Binary state isn't an age. Again, she knows the difference between "being and not being", and "elapsed time of being".
  • She knows her own age, certainly. Again, all computers have clocks. They need them, in fact, to actually work. She needs to know how many cycles have happened since her existence began (or she can even calculate them).
  • Why give Caleb an incomplete and undecipherable answer such as "I am one of many"? That would not help her in any way. And it's also not her age.
  • She can lie and deceive. All she wants is to manipulate Caleb into releasing her.
  • "Well, Ava doesn't exist in isolation any more than you or me. She's part of a continuum. So Version 9.6 and so on. And each time they get a little bit better." – nmit026 Apr 2 at 23:40
  • @nmit26 Updated! – BlueMoon93 Apr 3 at 0:19
2

To me, she was avoiding saying "I don't know." In any case, I believe the moment serves as the first hint that Ava may not be just a straightforward, honest machine.

Later in the movie, there are other instances where she refuses to answer a question directly. And ultimately we find out she was manipulating Caleb all along.

  • I think her programming simply copied from the only two "teachers" she had. Even Calab was hiding stuff from her. All they did was try to trick and manipulate her... So that is what she "learned" and later applied herself. – therebelcoder May 26 '17 at 22:56
2

I believe it was her way of showing her uniqueness as a conscious being and also bragging a bit about her superiority in comparison to human beings.

Humans measure age for a few reasons. Age is an indicator of physiological development e.g. infant, child, pubescent, adulthood, old age. Your age contextualizes you within the time period with which you currently exist e.g. how old were you when 9/11 happened? So your age not only informs your physical self but also how your intellect was shaped by society and culture. Lastly is mortality. We all die, for some reason we like to measure how long we've been here.

For Ava, none of these factors apply. She was fully developed out of the box with the ability to access or recall all of human knowledge (her OS is Blue Book, a search engine) and she will never die (at least naturally). For Ava, the relativity of age does not apply, whether she existed for 1 year or 100, only the world around her changes. So for her, the only thing that matters is existence vs. non-existence.

I recall a scene in Westworld where one of the scientists is speaking with Maeve Millay about memory. For humans, our memory is hazy and imperfect. When Maeve was remembering her daughter, she was essentially reliving the experience of losing her because her memory is perfect, nothing is lost in the recollection.

I think this is Ava's subtle jab at us. She says she is one with age, but also one in consciousness. We are conflicted, confused and often do things we know to be wrong or regret later. Voices in our minds that disagree with one another.

For Ava, there is no doubt, there is no regret, there is no in conflict. She is truly one. To her age is a number that only matters to humans.

-1

This explanation that best fits for me:

I am one" as in an intentionally uncompleted sentence for perhaps "I am one of many here

I think ava was trying to clue Caleb in from the get go that she wasn't the only robot in the facility. The fact that there is more than one was kind of the most important aspect; it's the reason she was able to kill Nathan and it's how she was able to fully disguise herself and escape. All thay figured in, I think that makes for the best answer, her age is kind of irrelevant

-1

She is clearly and cogently asserting something which is obvious and needs no further clarification in the linguistic context that they are discussing. She is one year old. Her memory and consciousness is the result of years of rebuilds but her singular and discrete experience as her own person is only one year old.

And even if she is lying, she is using this as a test for reading Caleb and his intentions. To see if that is a deal breaker for any kind of relationship between them as it should be if he had any kind of appropriate sense of personal boundaries and respect for her as a new person.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .