14

Is Captain America captain of the Avengers team? I am saying this because Captain America takes most decisions and once in Avengers: Age of Ultron Tony Stark mentions that he is just the financier and designs everything, Captain is the owner.

  • 1
    Can't say about the owner, but he could be the leader, as suggested by wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avengers_%28comics%29 – Ankit Apr 29 '15 at 11:23
  • Isn't Nick fury the leader? – DustinDavis Apr 30 '15 at 2:38
  • @DustinDavis Since the events of the Winter Soldier SHIELD (and Fury) are pretty much out of the equation. Fury only ever wanted to create and inspire that team, he never really seemed to be an actual part of it. – Napoleon Wilson Apr 30 '15 at 8:54
  • I believe it is a military rank, possibly attained before his transformation. – Arif Burhan May 11 '16 at 1:45
15

I would say that, if there had to be one, Cap would be the obvious choice. As others have mentioned, he has a history of leading others from his work before he was encapsulated in the ice. He also is very mission-oriented and very much interested in the greater good at his own personal cost. Whether this makes someone a good leader or not is debatable but when considering the goal of The Avengers they seem to be positives.

Why not the others?

Thor tends to wander off back to Asgard to take care of things there and it's difficult to lead a group when you have multiple priorities. He may have more battle experience but Earth is (arguably) secondary to Asgard.

Banner tends to wander off because he's not in control of the Hulk's power and doesn't want to hurt others, and lacks confidence. He's a great scientific mind but his heart isn't in the fighting.

Stark has more money than god and more brains than Einstein but he's very self-centered. Sometimes it takes a bit of prodding for him to do the "right" thing and his version of what's right isn't always the same as what's conventionally considered "right". Plus, as Fury was the one setting up The Avengers and intentionally tried to keep Stark out, he doesn't seem to be trusted as a leader.

Romanoff is used to working alone. She'll work as part of a team when necessary but her background is as an assassin/spy, a character type prone to working solo. And, yes, I'll play the misogyny card... she's also a girl. Girls don't generally get to lead men in superhero media.

Barton shows a lot of leadership qualities and the team does look to him often, which is shown pretty clearly in Age of Ultron. But he's also very modest and his family is clearly very important to him, so I think he'd avoid the position of leadership even if it was offered to him.

Plus, if you look at the end of Age of Ultron, at who's left for The Avengers team, it's a completely different group of people and the only two from those above are Cap and Romanoff.

Oh, and what about Fury?

Well, I'm pretty sure they make it clear a couple of times that, while SHIELD may have been behind creating the Avengers, they're not going to run the group. Fury has his own things to work on, managing what's left of SHIELD (as discussed in Agents of SHIELD). They'll be there for back-up if needed, as seen in Age of Ultron but they're two separate entities.

  • Clearly the best of all the various opinion pieces on this question to date. – Napoleon Wilson May 4 '15 at 9:24
  • 1
    The contrast to Barton is IMHO emphasised even further in the way that the movie seems to make it pretty clear that the Captain doesn't really have anything else in his life other than his conviction for his job (probably also partly due to his "out-of-time-ness"), as his "greatest fear" scenes seem to emphasize as well. – Napoleon Wilson May 4 '15 at 9:40
  • I agree @NapoleonWilson . That was what I was trying to imply by saying he's "Mission-oriented". :) – Catija May 4 '15 at 9:43
  • 1
    @Catija It's also worth pointing out that Tony actually refers to Steve as being in charge in Avengers: Age of Ultron - "Actually he's the boss.... I just pay for everything and design everything, make everyone look cooler." – Dr R Dizzle Sep 15 '15 at 14:10
4

In the MCU, Captain America is shown to be the leader. This is evident from the main battle in Avengers (2012), where Tony Stark tells Captain to make the battle plan.

To go off the scenes,

  1. Captain has military experience.
  2. Captain has leadership experience (having led a team against HYDRA back in the day).
  3. He also has formal military training.

These points make most people think of him as the leader of the team.

  • Of course, the leader doesn't need to be told to make the battle plan. That makes it seem like Stark delegated the task. – cde Nov 11 '15 at 7:47
3

If by captain you mean "Leader" then yes. From all the Avengers Captain America has the most experience in combat and leading a team from his battles in WW2 (with the exception of Thor maybe). This qualifies him to lead the team because he's able to make quick decisions and form a battle plan while still being able to fight well without being too distracted.

3

Captain America is the leader for the Avengers. If we look back at the past movies for the Marvel Cinematic Universe, there are many points leading to this. Iron Man is taken off the team for the Avengers in Iron Man 2 after Black Widow's report on his life. When they later put him on the team in The Avengers, it is to look at Selvig's research at first, since he is just a consultant. He is later added to the team. Captain America was seen as an American hero in the 1940s for helping in WWII, and was known across the globe. He was seen as a symbol of hope for Americans, showing how strong we were against our enemies. Getting found in the ice probably sparked the public due to the fact that they had heard the stories of the American hero. S.H.I.E.L.D most likely put him as the leader of the team also because of this, as the public would be more open minded to the Avengers. Though Captain America is said by Tony in the Age of Ultron trailer to be the captain, there are many points that show this in the first place.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .