3

This is a major hassle for me because I like watching movies late at night and I live in a city row house where neighbors sometimes complain of noise. When I have the volume set to something reasonable during the regular conversation parts of the movie, that same system volume level outputs a significantly louder sound when some violence kicks in or the soundtrack to the extent of having to rush to my remote to turn it down. Then I have to turn it back up when it's over because I can't hear conversations at the same volume level at which this increased input volume was tolerable. I also have some delicate sensory sensitivities (I can't handle very loud or certain sounds) so this is a problem.

I have never experienced this situation where I actually found the drastic variation in the sound volume something justified, which made the movie more enjoyable. IOW, I always find it a hassle.

Why are some movie parts much louder than others?

My entertainment setup consists of a projector, DVD player, Roku box for streaming, Sony receiver, and a 5+sub Harman Kardon speakers. You could say it is a fairly sophisticated setup and I wouldn't mind, if possible, to configure some setting to make the sound level more uniform coming out of the receiver regardless of how the input is encoded.

  • 1
    If you want to help your neighbors, lose the woofer (which is best for explosions and gun fire etc.) and raise the rest of the speakers off the floor and away from the walls. – Andrew Thompson Mar 31 '15 at 17:51
  • I can experiment without the woofer but the 5 little speakers are all mounted on the walls facing neighbors, so that's not subject to change – amphibient Mar 31 '15 at 17:53
  • "mounted on the walls facing neighbors,.." What, DYM the wall (with speakers) is next to/shared with the neighbors, or the neighbors are 'opposite' the wall? I was thinking that if the speaker wall was shared by the neighbors it would be the worst. But I think the biggest problems can be solved by disconnecting the woofer. Those vibrations go into and are carried by the superstructure much more so than the higher frequencies. – Andrew Thompson Mar 31 '15 at 18:05
  • the walls are separating my house from the neighbors, it's not that the speakers point towards the neighbors – amphibient Mar 31 '15 at 18:18
2

This is called dynamic range. In the simplest terms, imagine that you have a fixed numeric scale from 1 to 100 which tells you how loud something is, and you want all sounds in your recording to be reasonably representative of the actual sounds within the context of all the other sounds in the recording.

So for an action movie, you want the explosions to be 100 and "ambient silence" to be 1. Everything else needs to be in the middle somewhere and still be believable: you want gunshots at point blank to be louder than casual conversation.

If you adjust volume for listening to dialog, now the other stuff is booming. But if the audio engineer sets the dialog at 80, now the gunshots sound like popcorn. Sort of a catch-22.

As for how to mitigate this, some TVs or receivers have "low dynamic range" or "quiet mode" etc. setting in the audio preferences. Most dialog is in the center channel, so you can try lowering the volume of the other channels. I have found that choosing "stereo" instead of 5.1 can improve the volume level of dialog.

Some of the methods for "fixing" this on the fly involve look-ahead methods which can introduce time delay between video and audio. Not a big deal for devices which allow for adjustment (my TV has a latency setting).

Further google/reading: "loudness war" "dynamic range audio"

2

Check your TV or receiver for audio settings. My TV has a couple different ones, one of which acts as a normalizer which keeps the volume pretty much at a set peak. Another one brings the voices more out front, which is important because I don't have a home theater in my bedroom and when the audio is on "Movie" setting all I hear are the built-in speakers rattling.

As for your original question of why, it's all part of building a dynamic or a mood. Try watching Jaws or any horror movie on mute and see how much of a different experience certain scenes are versus with the volume on.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .