2

The technology has greatly improved since South Park's pilot episode, why has the style of the show not been changed?

  • 9
    I believe it is an artistic decision and not due to a limitation in technology. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Park#Animation – bobbyalex Oct 16 '14 at 5:12
  • 14
    Why would they suddenly up and transform the show's signature look for no reason, just because they could? That would be like the Simpsons suddenly doing everything in 3D. It's ludicrous. – Lightness Races in Orbit Oct 16 '14 at 9:11
  • note that they have done highly advanced 3-d style animation in brief spurts in the middle of episodes, largely for the humor value (e.g. mocking action movies or similar gags.) – KutuluMike Oct 16 '14 at 12:03
  • 10
    why wasn't this question written in 3D? – JamesRyan Oct 16 '14 at 12:14
  • 1
    @JamesRyan There is this faux 3D shadow around the question author's avatar... – his Oct 16 '14 at 18:02
4

Would 3-D animation make the content any better? George Lucas took advantage of the latest special effects available to film with the prequel trilogy which many fans say don't hold a candle to the original. When he "remastered" the original trilogy with special editions, many fans revolted.

Look at video games, some of the most critically acclaimed games have simple animations and graphics (Minecraft, Fez, etc.), while there are countless graphic powerhouse games that are commercial and critical failures.

South Park is funny because of the content. The barebones animation is a signature of the series. Why change it?

  • This answer is based on comparison, not on data released by South Park itself (which is available). – invalid_id Oct 20 '14 at 4:21
20

According to this article from Creative Planet Network

"We have the technology, and our animators have the skills to do 3-D," says supervising producer Anne Garefino. "We don't want it to look computery,"agrees director of animation Eric Stough, who's been on board since the pilot. "We want it to look as crappy as possible."

16

They do use 3D animation software. However, from the beginning the cut-out paper look is what they wanted to achieve with CG after finding out the difficulties of using real paper cut-outs.

The decision to stay with the paper cut-out look was made from the beginning, they want everything to look as cartoonish as possible, down to the movements and appearance of the characters. It also adds to the branding, one can immediately recognize a show of South Park by its looks.

More information

5

The show's style of animation is inspired by the paper cut-out cartoons made by Terry Gilliam for Monty Python's Flying Circus

, of which Parker and Stone have been lifelong fans.

After the pilot for subsequent episodes have been produced by computer animation, providing a similar look to the originals while requiring a fraction of the time to produce.

Beginning with season five, the animators began using Maya instead of PowerAnimator. The studio now runs a 120-processor render farm that can produce 30 or more shots an hour. PowerAnimator and Maya are high-end programs mainly used for 3D computer graphics, while co-producer and former animation director, Eric Stough, notes that PowerAnimator was initially chosen because its features helped animators retain the show's "homemade" look.

On a different note, many times the creators do not want to opt for the latest technology for their movies or shows. This could be based on personal like and dislike and yes it is an artistic decision as mentioned correctly by Bobby Alexander in his comment. A similar incident worth noting is Chris Nolan's choice of not shooting Dark Knight Rises in 3D at a time when almost everyone else was doing it. Wikipedia says that

Nolan elected not to film in 3-D, but instead stated that he intended to focus on improving image quality and scale using the IMAX format

So while South Park does use some of the latest technology, its current look and feel depends upon the creators' artistic decision.

1

Also due to branding you don't want to change something that works. The show is a screaming success. Changing it might run the path when Coke introduced New Coke and failed miserably

  • Exactly. I love the show more than I did 10 years ago. (More than I can say for other cartoons!) South Park is never afraid of poking fun of itself - even the "lazy" triple episodes (like Imaginationland, Game of Thrones trilogy) they parody by turning it (the stick) into a video game (The Stick of Truth)! Crude occasionally, but fantastic and so thankful I can watch it free on... oh, SPStudios changed to Hulu :( – Aussie Cryptocurrency Oct 17 '14 at 14:30
1

The quote I like best, referring to the software used to make South Park: "(using this 3D software) is basically building a sandcastle with a bulldozer".

That's the whole reason they use the software; to remain topical (episodes finished in a week, handed into Comedy Central on the Wednesday itself, ie tonight's episode wasn't submitted when you woke this morning!) because they aren't bogged down with Michael Bay-ism.

You must log in to answer this question.