11

There is a scene in Watchmen (2009) on Mars with Dr. Manhattan. Every time I watch the movie I'm wondering what exactly is this crystal/diamond thing we can see on mars.

crystal thing

13

First of all, what this thing actually is, it's nothing more than a huge glass structure that Dr. Manhattan creates out of Mars sand. But to understand why he builds that, we have to look at his character a bit (at least as far as I'm able to do). I'll draw a bit of information from the comic here, not entirely sure by now how much of this is also part of the movie, but the overall themes should match (especially considering how true to the source material the movie was).

When Dr. Manhattan left earth this was because he was currently fed up with humanity (and probably also felt some guilt for Janey's cancer, not knowing that he wasn't the cause). To compensate this he takes refuge in the solitude of Mars. And as the son of a watchmaker, Jon Osterman learned from his father to admire the precision of such a watch as a structue of many simple parts that precisely interlock with each other. And I guess at this point he searches refuge in creating such a complex and precise structure out of something as simple as the sand of Mars, all while reflecting about his past life and trying to understand the nature of time and determination itself and the problems of cause and effect. And the corresponding chapter of the novel is indeed also called "Watchmaker", reinforcing this attitude.

enter image description here enter image description here enter image description here


In addition to that, if we understand Dr. Manhattan with his godlike powers as an exaggeration (or perversion?) of Superman, this walkable structure in the solitude of Mars might as well be understood as an allusion to Superman's crystalline Fortress of Solitude in the lonesome depths of Antarctica.

  • But what is the purpose of this huge watch-like instrument? Does Dr. Manhattan build it just because he can, in sort of a therapeutic manner or he wishes to use this in the future for something. – Sayan Sep 5 '14 at 11:52
  • 2
    @KeyBrdBasher I don't think it is supposed to actually do anything meaningful (he only uses it fly around in with Laurie). I think it really only has what one could call "therapeutic value", as it helps him to understand the meaning of determination by example. But other than that he really just seems to do it because he can and to create something (at the end of the story he also mentions that he'll maybe create life one day wherever he goes). – Napoleon Wilson Sep 5 '14 at 12:58
  • Thanks for the clarification @NapoleonWilson. Much appreciated. – Sayan Sep 8 '14 at 9:18
0

As others have said, Manhattan has guilt. I think he hated that humans die and wanted to create something that showed time (his wheel clock thing) but would not die. This clock wheel will not die like humans do. But it will be there with him. If you notice when he was building it he was in a meditative pose while hovering. Buddhism has a lot of talk of getting away from it all to find inner peace. The Buddha himself discovered he could not always be alone and that he simply must have some interaction with others. Maybe this wheel clock thing is otehrs to Dr Manhattan.

-4

I think since Doctor manhattan was haunted by guilt of the cancer ,he thinks he's also responsible for the end of it, so he built him self a time machine to travel back and forth in time to fix the problem of his guilt.

  • 2
    What evidence do you have that this is a time machine? Further, what evidence do you have that Doctor Manhattan would need to build a machine to traverse time? – MattD Jul 20 '15 at 3:02
  • 2
    Please share some more details and explanation. – Panther Jul 20 '15 at 3:03

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .