22

Charles Xavier died in X-Men Last Stand. But according to the post credits scene of that movie and this link, Charles transferred his mind to his brain-dead twin brother's body. So now that he is alive and using his brain dead brother's body, shouldn't he be able to walk? But the Days of Future Past's dystopian future shows him in a wheelchair. Why is that?

  • 1
    At the moment, everything that I've seen lists that as a continuity problem, which means it hasn't been explained/retconned yet. – JohnP May 27 '14 at 18:11
  • Its a multiverse. The answer is lame, I think this should explain. – ashveli Mar 20 '17 at 9:52
15

Days of Future Past reveals, albeit somewhat subtly and with more inference than direct exposition, the reason for Xavier's inability to walk...

His lower paralysis has manifested as a result of the psychological trauma of the gunshot, but his psyche has embraced it implicitly as part of his mutancy. When Xavier takes Mutant supressing serum, he regains the ability to walk: meaning his paraplegia is directly linked with his powers. In order to use his powers, he must lose the ability to walk.

Personally, I think this was supposed to be conveyed as part of his secondary-stage mutation: which was perhaps too much of a concept to fit into an already crowded narrative.

The real unanswered question, is why does Xavier still possess the likeness of Patrick Stewart, when X-Men: The Last Stand shows that body being atomized and his consciousness transferred into another... A question I intend to ask, myself!

  • 5
    Makes sense! And the reason being said for Xavier's likeness to Patrick Stewart is that he actually transferred his mind to his brain dead twin brother's body. Apparently this was discussed in director's commentary in the DVDs. – Lakshmi Narayanan May 28 '14 at 10:43
1

When he dies in X-Men 3 and transfers his consciousness into his brain-dead twin brother who was mentioned earlier in X-Men 3, he is still in the wheelchair because its has become a part of his mutation. His brain/consciousness requires that he can't use his legs even though his brother's legs are fine - his brain still went through the trauma of paralysis so he won't be able to use his brother's legs.

0

I actually have an interesting theory about this.

There is no implicit link between the dark future timeline in Days of Future Past and the original trilogy and Wolverine spin offs other than the characters and the actors who portray them. People are assuming that the events of the dark future timeline shown in Days of Future Past are part of the same universe as the original trilogy and the Wolverine spin offs, despite a massive amount of evidence in the form of plot inconstitencies and continuity issues that this is not true.

I would go so far as to state that First Class and Days Of Future Past are a part of one X Men Universe, and that the original trilogy and the Wolverine spin offs are part of a seperate, now redunant universe. This would explain why Mystique and Professor X never acknowedged one another in the original trilogy, or that Bolivar Trask is a large, alive black man in X-Men: The Last Stand but a small, dead white man in the dark timeline of Days of Future Past, which people are assuming is the sequel to X-Men: The Last Stand. It explains away how Magneto would have ever escaped from prison after seemingly assassinating JFK to go on to be the bad guy of the original trilogy without Wolverine having gone into the past to set him free in the first place, as in the original trilogy we can just assume that was never implicated in the assassination of JFK.

It is now easier to think of the orignal trilogy and the Wolverine spin offs as another, entirely seperate universe that has no cannonical impact on the new universe that was created with First Class and continued with Days of Future Past.

0

As brain dead from a baby, his brother never learned to walk so Xavier would have to build up his muscles in his new body to be able to walk again. That's probably a future movie when he can finally walk again.

  • The same would be said for all his muscles, eye, mouth, arms, etc. Very Neo released from the Matrix like. No reason his legs wouldn't work while his arms do. – cde Jun 4 '16 at 18:46
0

That's crazy. So if he had cut himself while shaving that morning, his twin brother would mysteriously also get a cut just because Charles transferred his mind into him?

And if the paralysis can't possibly be a part of his mutation. His mutation was bring able to use a certain section of his brain for higher functions like psionic attacks etc. He had injured his spine while battling Magneto and that's how he got paralysed waist down. And since the spine and brain are connected, any attempt to cure his paralysis would mean losing touch with the part of his mind that gave him his powers and vice versa.

But in the new body of his brother, no such injury exists. The neurons are not damaged and all is good. So if Charles can't seem to walk, it is because he didn't try. It's been so long that he has forgotten that he can walk...maybe lost his will force.

It's just like a patient who recovers after a fracture to the leg. Charles needs therapy and care.

  • 1
    It's called conversion disorder. His mind makes him paralyzed because he believes he is. And it is tied with how strong his mind is. – cde Jul 17 '16 at 13:44
-3

The reason that proffesor x still needs the use of a wheelchair is because in the end of ; x-men the last stand he transfers all his MIND to the body of his brain-dead twin brother. But when proffesor x was killed he was still in his wheelchair so the timeline is leaving off from the point he was terminated,thus he would still be ina wheelchair to portray and keep the explanation from first class.

  • 2
    The question is not why he is in a wheelchair in the new timeline at the end of Days of Future Past, but why he was in a wheelchair after tranferring his mind into his supposedly not paralyzed twin brother's body. – Napoleon Wilson Jun 13 '14 at 18:09
  • Answer don't seem to consitent with the question as explained by Tom – Panther Aug 5 '15 at 4:36

You must log in to answer this question.

protected by Napoleon Wilson Mar 21 '17 at 14:37

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .