In Men In Black, how much control, if any, does the government actually have in the M.I.B. department?

When J is first being introduced to the department, K tells him the story of an "underfunded agency (started by the government) used to try and make contact with other life."

The very next day when J arrives for the second time... he asks K which part of the government it is that they're involved with, K responds by telling him that they're not involved with the government at all, "The government asks too many questions." He then explains to J that they are able to fund their operations by putting a patent on different devices they confiscate from the aliens.

If the government started the operation years ago, how are they not involved now?

  • 4
    "If the government started the operation years ago, how are they not involved now?" The M.I.B. zapped the people in gov. with their little 'memory erase' devices. ..Obviously. Commented Mar 3, 2014 at 8:13

1 Answer 1


Using the US government as an example: There are agencies and functions which exist within the Executive Branch of the government whose purposes are to perform certain intelligence gathering operations which may violate US law or which may create embarrassment for a sitting administration. These agencies and functions thus operate under "black budgets" and are only peripherally connected to the government for reasons of national security.

In the Men In Black universe, it is made clear by statements and the use of the Neuralizer memory erasing devices that the existence of alien life is not known to to the general public. To maintain this facade, the government seems willing to extend certain law enforcement and intelligence powers to the MIB (arrest and detention powers, intelligence gathering, the use of deadly force, etc) while allowing the agency to operate outside of normal and legal channels.

This is probably for reasons of "plausible deniability" (e.g. if asked under oath if the agency exists, then a government official can truthfully state that it does not without incurring perjury charges) as well insulating MIB's operations from legislative oversight and media scrutiny.

The government may be "involved" in some aspects of the MIB program (in the first film military officers are shown as being tested for candidacy with the agency, for example) however, it seem to keep the agency's daily activities at arm's length and its very existence is likely only known to a select few people for reasons of security and deniability.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .