Why do the MacManus brothers not consider Rocco to be scum? He's been in the mafia for 18 years (IIRC) and has to have gotten his paws dirty. Is he small fry or is he given a pass because he's a friend?

Similarly, Il Duce was a violent hit man. Why is he given the clean bill of health?

2 Answers 2


God it's been ages since I've seen this, but IIRC, Rocco was only a delivery guy. He never really got his hands dirty, and only ever was given 1 task to "make" him. As such, he was also seen as someone who had information. The brothers most likely kept him alive for these reasons.

As for Il Duce, it may be because they realized he was their father. The scene where they are praying over Rocco, Duce walks in, hears what they are saying, and then finishes the prayer for them. He then joins them in their cause.

  • One task to make him? Was this when he assisted the mafioso who killed an entire family? Sep 19, 2013 at 7:28
  • @coleopterist: The task he was given to take out the Russian family.
    – PiousVenom
    Sep 19, 2013 at 13:03
  • This task? 6 bullets for 9 men? Sep 19, 2013 at 13:25
  • @coleopterist: Yes, the one where he pretended to be a bell boy, but the Brothers had already killed everyone in the room.
    – PiousVenom
    Sep 19, 2013 at 13:31

Il duce wouldn't kill women or children, and when he is introduced into the plot it is said that "he had a thing for killing wiseguys". You could say that he was a hitman with a moral code, which just happens to align quite well with the MacManus brothers own sense of morality. The brothers didn't know this at their first encounter (nor did Il Duce) but when they realize they are family with the same goal in life I guess it makes sense to join forces.

As for Rocco. A bit harder to explain, but Rocco isn't evil, he just works for evil men. IIRC in the scene in the kitchen where they start talking about doing this for real, they say something along the lines of them deciding who's evil and not (and thus, gets to live or not).

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .