10

During the final fight sequence between Spock and Khan. Spock applies the Vulcan nerve pinch to Khan, who lets out a scream of pain but doesn't collapse.

Why didn't the nerve pinch work?

|improve this question
7

In the original series "Assignment: Earth", the human derived from a hidden planet, Gary Seven, shrugs off a Vulcan nerve pinch without any discomfort at all.

Khan is not incapacitated by it, but does create much pain for him—so presumably it would be worse for anyone else. We don't know if his superior muscularity guards the nerves or if his genetically engineered nervous system is better able to cope with the paralysis effects normal to humans.

Presumably then, the maneuver is most effective on more weakly engineered humans. The most advanced are less affected by it.

|improve this answer
  • I personally think it has to do with his superior nervous system. Earlier in the movie we see him take a phaser straight on and it didn't slow him down all that much. Only consecutive shots really had an affect. – DForck42 Jun 3 '13 at 13:53
  • @DForck42 - see my comment below - It's worked on other Eugenics humans of the same "breed" as Khan in 'Space Seed'. – JohnP Jun 3 '14 at 14:38
  • Later in the movie, when on board the Dreadnought class ship, he takes a stun shot from a phaser on the bridge and goes down immediately, while the effects weren't lasting it knocked him out completely. – BB Stacker Jun 4 '14 at 12:43
  • @BBStacker - One wonders, then, why he wasn't felled by the multiple stun shots fired by Uhura on the floating barge later in the movie? – JohnP Jun 4 '14 at 14:27
2

Spock's Vulcan Nerve Pinch was much less effective on Khan, due to his superior genetic engineering. Although, it had a temporary painful effect, Khan, as stated in the film, was the most dangerous adversary they have/had ever faced.

|improve this answer
  • What does being a dangerous adversary have to do with it? Also, in 'Space Seed' (ST:TOS), the original appearance of Khan, one of the engineered humans is subdued instantly by Spock using the nerve pinch. – JohnP Jun 3 '14 at 14:37
  • 1
    Interesting...There is an inconsistency with the new and old then. – BB Stacker Jun 4 '14 at 12:35
  • Heh...that's hardly news. :) – JohnP Jun 4 '14 at 14:25
1

It makes sense that in Khan's world, genetially enhanced humans are placed in a meritocracy, the most perfect (i.e. him) at the top, and less enhanced people in lower ranking positions. Therefore, it is perfectly possible that the engineered human who goes down instantly in Space Seed is one of these less-enhanced people, maybe only with enhanced mental capabilities (like Bashir in DS9)?

Khan has been engineered to a level of physical perfection well beyond normal humans, and presumably even beyond many of the alien species, so it's only logical that his neuromusculature is more resistant to an attack such as the Vulcan nerve pinch than other people's.

|improve this answer
  • Also, when he is shot by a phaser on the bridge of the "Vengeance", certainly on the versions of the movie that I have seen there is a brief cut-away to his face, where it is clear he is still conscious and only playing possum, biding his time until Kirk, Marcus and Scotty are distracted. – We didn't burn him Apr 6 '17 at 22:50

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .