28

In The Empire Strikes Back, when Luke is leaving for Bespin, Yoda implores him to remember his failure at the cave. Obviously, this is a reference to the cave that was strong in the Dark Side and where Luke faced the Vader illusion. However, what was Luke's failure? What should he have done in the cave?

  • 3
    Cross dupe of scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/86024/… – Charles Sep 30 at 2:45
  • 4
    One thing to consider is that Yoda said the cave was strong with the Dark Side, but that doesn't mean it actually was. We know that Yoda is comfortable using deception as a teaching tool. – Todd Wilcox Sep 30 at 16:14
  • 2
    In Clone Wars when Yoda goes to Degobah and meets with Quigon's force ghost he also is told that the cave is strong with the Dark Side and also goes in to face his dark self. – Delta_G Oct 1 at 17:51
56

Luke's failure in the cave was his fear.

  • He was afraid of what he might find so he took his light saber with him to fight what he might encounter - despite Yoda having told him that he would only face what he took with him.
  • In his fear, he "killed" the Darth Vader apparition. It wasn't a reasoned response to a threat, it was a reflex reaction to a fright.
  • The dead Vader apparition had Luke's face, revealing Luke's deeper fear that he may fall to the dark side.

Luke's failure was that he was still ruled by fear - and that can be manipulated to make him fall to the dark side.

There was nothing specific Luke should have done differently. To not fail the cave encounter, he had to be free of fear. That could lead to many results in the cave - but we don't know what could have gone differently because he was afraid.

| improve this answer | |
  • 3
    "Confronting fear is the destiny of a Jedi." - Luke to Rey, The Rise of Skywalker – Darth Locke Sep 30 at 15:21
  • 17
    It took me literally decades to figure out whose face that was on the Vader apparition. – Almo Sep 30 at 15:25
  • 2
    While Luke did draw and activate his lightsaber first (and I've always believed that if Luke hadn't done that, the Vader figure would have just stood there and perhaps never even had a lightsaber) the Vader apparition did attack Luke first. – Todd Wilcox Sep 30 at 16:12
  • 4
    I think fear is a good part of the answer, and I also think we could add more to our analysis of Luke's state of mind/emotions in the cave. To me the scene immediately before the scene in the cave is not there by accident (it's really one long scene, ending with the cave, IMHO). Luke and Yoda talk about the differences between the dark and light sides, how to stay on the light side, and how to tell the dark from the light. Yoda talks about calm, peace, knowledge and defense, and Luke fails to follow that tutelage. And he shows both fear and aggression. – Todd Wilcox Sep 30 at 16:19
18

After thinking, rewatching the scene, and considering the comments, I've heavily edited my answer.

Luke's improper actions:

  • Yoda told him he would not need his weapons, but he took them inside anyway
  • When the cave showed him Vader (which Luke must have in some way brought into the cave, since all the cave contains is "what you take with you"), instead of being calm and at peace to know the dark from light, and instead of using the force for knowledge and defense, he drew and activated his lightsaber
  • After the Vader figure attacks, Luke does not back away, flee, force jump out of the cave, or otherwise try to avoid killing the Vader figure - he meets aggression with aggression

It doesn't seem unreasonable to me to see the cave as a kind of spiritual or force "mirror". It shows you something about yourself. So we can interpret Yoda's use of the word "failure" to mean that Luke did some thing(s) wrong regarding the cave (bullets above), and/or that what the cave reflected back to Luke shows that Luke is not yet ready and not yet a Jedi.

I think focusing on the word "failure" and trying to pick it apart might be missing the point: The cave showed, one way or another, where Luke is on the path to being a Jedi, and it wasn't great.

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    So, the failure was bringing a tool of violence? – Daniel Walker Sep 30 at 2:18
  • asked and answered – Jason P Sallinger Sep 30 at 11:17
  • @Daniel Walker: Todd's answer seems to be "Yoda says failure to make Luke think it was a failure and move him away from the dark side", not because it was, in fact, a failure – josinalvo Sep 30 at 15:12
  • Compare with the tunnel scene from Stalker. "No guns!" youtu.be/usB180xcYEY?t=531 – David Tonhofer Oct 2 at 12:06
  • The cave is definitely force related, but it is actually associated with The Dark Side! It made it easier for Yoda to hide out there. Here's info about the "dark side" cave: starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Dark_Side_Cave – Darth Locke Oct 3 at 14:28
3

Emphasis is his "Failure" stemmed from the lesson. Do not rely on your dark impulses to confront evil

| improve this answer | |
2

I feel Luke's failure is his impatience.

Yoda: If you end your training now, if you choose the quick and easy path, as Vader did, you will become an agent of evil.

We see it when Luke obstinately takes his weapons into the cave, against Yoda's suggestion:

Yoda: Your weapons... you will not need them.

What he takes into the cave with him is actually his Skywalker heritage; it alludes to how Luke is the son of Vader:

Luke: What's in there?
Yoda: Only what you take with you.

We see a premonition of what would happen were Luke to simply destroy Vader with his lightsaber. In particular, we see Luke's lifeless face on Vader's apparition, which highlights the consequences of killing one's own father: it's akin to killing oneself. Luke doesn't understand the premonition because he is not yet ready.

Nevertheless, with his friends suffering, Luke impatiently seeks a kind of "quick fix" (defeating Vader solves everything). It is in this context when Yoda says:

Yoda: Remember your failure at the cave!

As Luke matures, in Return of the Jedi, we see that Luke has overcome his impatience:

Obi-Wan Kenobi: You're no longer so reckless now, Luke. You are strong and patient. And now, you must face Darth Vader again!

He even discards his lightsaber vs. both Vader and the Emperor.

| improve this answer | |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .