28

In The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers there is a scene where Saruman and Grima stand on the balcony of Orthanc, the black, impenetrable tower of Isengard. Saruman shows his army to Grima for the first time, and Grima shed a tear. Why did he shed a tear?

(the scene is around 2:05:00 in the extended version)

39

In the book it was explained that Grima's final plan in Rohan (or at least what Saruman had promised him) was to marry Éowyn and become the next King of Rohan (of course still at the orders of Saruman). Not only did he want the throne but he also wanted Éowyn herself.

Saruman had just ordered his army to go to Helm's Deep and kill everyone there, which would have included Éowyn. This is when Grima, counting on Saruman's army victory, shed a tear (for Éowyn).

  • 1
    Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation has been moved to chat. – Napoleon Wilson Oct 21 at 12:48
  • 5
    This question is about the movies--do you have any scene or script information that indicates this answer is accurate? Having seen the extended edition of the movie multiple times, I don't recall any such indication. – TylerH Oct 21 at 18:08
  • @TylerH There is the scene where he tries to "flirt" with her in her chambers when she is grieving. But there is no indication that he loves Eowyn, he just wants her like he wants other things. youtube.com/watch?v=_VTMtrqqiH4 Nothing he would shed a tear about. – Frank Hopkins Oct 21 at 22:49
  • 1
    @TylerH: There is a movie scene alluding to this but the comment was moved to chat (IMO wrongly - though the continued discussion did need to be moved) – Flater Oct 22 at 9:45
  • 1
    @FrankHopkins and Flater - as I commented in chat, I don't agree with that interpretation of that scene. Even if I did, I don't think it relates at all to the one tear Grima shed at the site of the Uruk-hai army. He's a slimy evil guy (his name is "literally" grimy; he is the kind of person to find a massive fighting force of evil a "beautiful" thing at which to shed a tear in awe. – TylerH Oct 22 at 14:45
32

While I think @SJuan76's answer is on the right track, it's too specific. There is no indication he sheds a tear for Eowyn specifically, as he can't even be sure she's at Helm's Deep. I think many events indicate he's shedding a tear for the end of Rohan. There are multiple indications in the movie he's deep down still a proud man of Rohan.

  • After Isengard's fall he seems willing to accept Theoden's offer of redemption.
  • He eventually kills Saruman after the latter deeply insulted Rohan.
  • In a conversation with Eomer it is shown he wanted Eowyn as price for his betrayal. This indicates he both did not think Rohan to fall and he wanted a strong tie to the remaining country, choosing a wife of Royal descent, probably even ruling it as a Vazal of Saruman (though I admit this is a bit of conjecture).
  • Up until the events of the movie he was working a long con, essentially crippling the Rohan Military and head of state, but not (to his knowledge) bringing the destruction of Rohan.
  • The tear comes directly after Saruman stating "There will be no dawn for Men", or more specifically the Rohirrim.

This all strongly seems to suggest it is only at that moment he understands that Saruman will settle for nothing but the complete destruction of Rohan and he sheds a tear for his betrayed, but still beloved country.

20

Grima has just been arguing with Saruman about how strong Helm's Deep is and how it is virtually un-breachable. My interpretation is that he has always seen Helm's Deep as the ultimate in protection and power, and in this moment he is shown power that he's never known to be possible. He was unaware of the power of the black powder and he claims that there is no such army that can breach the walls only seconds later to be shown such an army in the Uruk Hai. He is overwhelmed by it all and sheds a tear at the "beauty" and "fear" of it all. He's shown the evidence of what he only seconds ago doubted was possible and this is his full "conversion" moment.

Below is the movie script taken from IMSDb.com and provides some of the insight and context I'm referring to.

Grima (V.O.): Helm’s Deep has one weakness. Its outer wall is solid rock but for a small culvert at its base which is little more than a drain.

[Camera turns to Gríma and Saruman at Orthanc. Saruman is pouring some dark dry substances into a vessel. Gríma is holding a lit candle in his hand.]

Grima: How? How can fire undo stone? What kind of device could bring down the wall?

[As he steps closer to the vessel, Saruman takes hold of Gríma’s hand and pushes the candle away from the vessel firmly.]

Saruman: If the wall is breached, Helm's Deep will fall.

[He walks away towards the balcony.]

Grima: [Following Saruman] Even if it is breached, it would take a number beyond reckoning, thousands to storm the keep.

Saruman: Tens of thousands.

Grima: But, my lord, there is no such force.

[Both of them came onto the balcony of the tower. Gríma suddenly sees and hears the enormous armies laid out below in neat rows and is astounded and awed. He continues to hold the extinguished candle aloft as he gapes at the vast army below. A horn is sounded, announcing the appearance of Saruman. A loud cheer is heard from the army. Saruman raises a hand.]

Saruman: A new power is rising. Its victory is at hand!

[The army cheers and roars.]

Saruman: This night, the land will be stained with the blood of Rohan! March to Helms Deep! Leave none alive!

[The camera keeps zooming out from the balcony over the incredible size of Saruman’s army, past Uruk-hai, spears, and banners and yet more Uruk-hai. The camera focuses back on Saruman who then raises his hands in the air]

Saruman: To war!!

[The army cheers and roars even louder.]

Saruman: [Sneers] There will be no dawn for Men.

[A tear flows down Gríma’s cheek. The Uruk-hai army began their march to Helm’s Deep.]

  • 7
    I'm not seeing how you go from a "'hah, Your whole race is going to die!' - Grima cries' script to deriving grima thought it a beautiful design. Actual tears of sadness about the end of one's known world make more sense than tears of joy about his absolute conversion. – KillianDS Oct 21 at 7:59
  • 3
    It seemed very clear to me that it was a tear shed upon seeing a thing of utter beauty (Grima is in general a very anti-Rohan character who hates the people in charge of the place). This is a much more accurate explanation of the movie than the accepted answer, which seems completely made up (even in the extended version there is no indication Grima is sad about losing out on some potential love interest). – TylerH Oct 21 at 18:07
  • @TylerH Check the comments on the other answer that were moved to chat — I’ve previously made the same observation as you, and I dimly recall this being Word of God via the director’s commentary but I wasn’t able to convince anybody. – Konrad Rudolph Oct 22 at 10:54
13

This question has a word of god answer on the SciFi sister site. Turns out, both theories are right, to some extent; that is: the tear is both from awe at the military might, and regret at the imminent destruction of mankind. Citing both the actor who played Gríma and the director (via the director’s commentary on the DVD of The Two Towers) the answer notes that the scene makes explicit reference to Nazi propaganda and military shows of force, which had the purpose of creating feelings of awe.

But the answer also cites the writer who notes Gríma’s regret at what he has unleashed. Here’s the relevant excerpt:

Brad Dourif (Gríma Wormtongue): There is no other character who could have brought over to the audience what was about to happen, who could have sold the awe. […] When you look at a picture of something, it isn’t the picture that sells it, you know. I mean the fact that he did an allusion to [the Nazi propaganda movie] “Triumph of the Will”, but that in of itself is not enough, but when you have the person that made it happen suddenly, absolutely come to grips with what it is that he has done, then it’s scary. […]

Peter Jackson (director): This is Nuremburg really. That is the obvious influence for all this stuff. That sort of imagery is so potent and it is useful to dip into those historical references just to press buttons in people.

Philippa Boyens (screenplay): I loved that performance from Brad Dourif just showing that Wormtongue was a man once — what has he done — what has he unleashed?

It’s worth noting that there is no indication that the tear was shed specifically for Éowyn.

  • 2
    Very good answer, and more balanced than either SJuan76's ("Éowyn!") or sanpaco's ("wow!"). – DevSolar Oct 24 at 9:17

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .