Skip to main content
added 87 characters in body
Source Link
OrangeDog
  • 4.2k
  • 1
  • 25
  • 29

Some knowledge of the book may give a greater understanding.

Clearly the plots do not directly follow each other, and the most obvious difference is that in the book, The Grasshopper Lies Heavy is a book, whereas in the series it is a series of motion pictures*. However, if we assume the central premise is the same then

the world portrayed is a fiction, and the films exist to reveal to the characters that they are not real

In such an interpretation, it does not really matter who "the man" is, or what the in-universe motivations are.

On the other hand, I believe there is not intended to be a definitive answer and the audience is free to come to their own conclusions. Your own explanation is perfectly reasonable, but I prefer one based on a multiverse theory of realities, where the films slip through from other realities

like Tagomi does in the final scene

and Hitler is "the man" (his residence is the only thing presented that could qualify as a literal "high castle") collecting them in order to understand the various possibilities and steer history to his design.

*Crucially, it is the same medium in which story is presented to us.


As of season two, we have definitive answers. The films

are brought from other worlds by individuals (such as Tagomi and Kotomishi) who are able to travel via meditation. The leaders of the Nazis and the Resistance are trying to find one that shows how to avoid nuclear Armageddon.

The Man in the High Castle

is Hawthorne Abendsen, a leader of the West Coast resistance, who maintains a large collection of films

it appears that their strategy is exactly as you describe.


Season three explores these mechanics and the Nazi endgame in greater detail.

Some knowledge of the book may give a greater understanding.

Clearly the plots do not directly follow each other, and the most obvious difference is that in the book, The Grasshopper Lies Heavy is a book, whereas in the series it is a series of motion pictures*. However, if we assume the central premise is the same then

the world portrayed is a fiction, and the films exist to reveal to the characters that they are not real

In such an interpretation, it does not really matter who "the man" is, or what the in-universe motivations are.

On the other hand, I believe there is not intended to be a definitive answer and the audience is free to come to their own conclusions. Your own explanation is perfectly reasonable, but I prefer one based on a multiverse theory of realities, where the films slip through from other realities

like Tagomi does in the final scene

and Hitler is "the man" (his residence is the only thing presented that could qualify as a literal "high castle") collecting them in order to understand the various possibilities and steer history to his design.

*Crucially, it is the same medium in which story is presented to us.


As of season two, we have definitive answers. The films

are brought from other worlds by individuals (such as Tagomi and Kotomishi) who are able to travel via meditation. The leaders of the Nazis and the Resistance are trying to find one that shows how to avoid nuclear Armageddon.

The Man in the High Castle

is Hawthorne Abendsen, a leader of the West Coast resistance, who maintains a large collection of films

it appears that their strategy is exactly as you describe.

Some knowledge of the book may give a greater understanding.

Clearly the plots do not directly follow each other, and the most obvious difference is that in the book, The Grasshopper Lies Heavy is a book, whereas in the series it is a series of motion pictures*. However, if we assume the central premise is the same then

the world portrayed is a fiction, and the films exist to reveal to the characters that they are not real

In such an interpretation, it does not really matter who "the man" is, or what the in-universe motivations are.

On the other hand, I believe there is not intended to be a definitive answer and the audience is free to come to their own conclusions. Your own explanation is perfectly reasonable, but I prefer one based on a multiverse theory of realities, where the films slip through from other realities

like Tagomi does in the final scene

and Hitler is "the man" (his residence is the only thing presented that could qualify as a literal "high castle") collecting them in order to understand the various possibilities and steer history to his design.

*Crucially, it is the same medium in which story is presented to us.


As of season two, we have definitive answers. The films

are brought from other worlds by individuals (such as Tagomi and Kotomishi) who are able to travel via meditation. The leaders of the Nazis and the Resistance are trying to find one that shows how to avoid nuclear Armageddon.

The Man in the High Castle

is Hawthorne Abendsen, a leader of the West Coast resistance, who maintains a large collection of films

it appears that their strategy is exactly as you describe.


Season three explores these mechanics and the Nazi endgame in greater detail.

added 62 characters in body
Source Link
OrangeDog
  • 4.2k
  • 1
  • 25
  • 29

Some knowledge of the book may give a greater understanding.

Clearly the plots do not directly follow each other, and the most obvious difference is that in the book, The Grasshopper Lies Heavy is a book, whereas in the series it is a series of motion pictures*. However, if we assume the central premise is the same then

the world portrayed is a fiction, and the films exist to reveal to the characters that they are not real

In such an interpretation, it does not really matter who "the man" is, or what the in-universe motivations are.

On the other hand, I believe there is not intended to be a definitive answer and the audience is free to come to their own conclusions. Your own explanation is perfectly reasonable, but I prefer one based on a multiverse theory of realities, where the films slip through from other realities

like Tagomi does in the final scene

and Hitler is "the man" (his residence is the only thing presented that could qualify as a literal "high castle") collecting them in order to understand the various possibilities and steer history to his design.

*Crucially, it is the same medium in which story is presented to us.


As of season two, we have definitive answers. The films

are brought from other worlds by individuals (such as Tagomi and Kotomishi) who are able to travel via meditation. The leaders of the Nazis and the Resistance are trying to find one that shows how to avoid nuclear Armageddon.

The Man in the High Castle

is Hawthorne Abendsen, a leader of the West Coast resistance, who maintains a large collection of films

it appears that their strategy is exactly as you describe.

Some knowledge of the book may give a greater understanding.

Clearly the plots do not directly follow each other, and the most obvious difference is that in the book, The Grasshopper Lies Heavy is a book, whereas in the series it is a series of motion pictures*. However, if we assume the central premise is the same then

the world portrayed is a fiction, and the films exist to reveal to the characters that they are not real

In such an interpretation, it does not really matter who "the man" is, or what the in-universe motivations are.

On the other hand, I believe there is not intended to be a definitive answer and the audience is free to come to their own conclusions. Your own explanation is perfectly reasonable, but I prefer one based on a multiverse theory of realities, where the films slip through from other realities

like Tagomi does in the final scene

and Hitler is "the man" (his residence is the only thing presented that could qualify as a literal "high castle") collecting them in order to understand the various possibilities and steer history to his design.

*Crucially, it is the same medium in which story is presented to us.


As of season two, we have definitive answers. The films

are brought from other worlds by individuals (such as Tagomi and Kotomishi) who are able to travel via meditation. The leaders of the Nazis and the Resistance are trying to find one that shows how to avoid nuclear Armageddon.

The Man in the High Castle

is Hawthorne Abendsen, a leader of the West Coast resistance, who maintains a large collection of films

Some knowledge of the book may give a greater understanding.

Clearly the plots do not directly follow each other, and the most obvious difference is that in the book, The Grasshopper Lies Heavy is a book, whereas in the series it is a series of motion pictures*. However, if we assume the central premise is the same then

the world portrayed is a fiction, and the films exist to reveal to the characters that they are not real

In such an interpretation, it does not really matter who "the man" is, or what the in-universe motivations are.

On the other hand, I believe there is not intended to be a definitive answer and the audience is free to come to their own conclusions. Your own explanation is perfectly reasonable, but I prefer one based on a multiverse theory of realities, where the films slip through from other realities

like Tagomi does in the final scene

and Hitler is "the man" (his residence is the only thing presented that could qualify as a literal "high castle") collecting them in order to understand the various possibilities and steer history to his design.

*Crucially, it is the same medium in which story is presented to us.


As of season two, we have definitive answers. The films

are brought from other worlds by individuals (such as Tagomi and Kotomishi) who are able to travel via meditation. The leaders of the Nazis and the Resistance are trying to find one that shows how to avoid nuclear Armageddon.

The Man in the High Castle

is Hawthorne Abendsen, a leader of the West Coast resistance, who maintains a large collection of films

it appears that their strategy is exactly as you describe.

added 441 characters in body
Source Link
OrangeDog
  • 4.2k
  • 1
  • 25
  • 29

Some knowledge of the book may give a greater understanding.

Clearly the plots do not directly follow each other, and the most obvious difference is that in the book, The Grasshopper Lies Heavy is a book, whereas in the series it is a series of motion pictures*. However, if we assume the central premise is the same then

the world portrayed is a fiction, and the films exist to reveal to the characters that they are not real

In such an interpretation, it does not really matter who "the man" is, or what the in-universe motivations are.

On the other hand, I believe there is not intended to be a definitive answer and the audience is free to come to their own conclusions. Your own explanation is perfectly reasonable, but I prefer one based on a multiverse theory of realities, where the films slip through from other realities

like Tagomi does in the final scene

and Hitler is "the man" (his residence is the only thing presented that could qualify as a literal "high castle") collecting them in order to understand the various possibilities and steer history to his design.

*Crucially, it is the same medium in which story is presented to us.


As of season two, we have definitive answers. The films

are brought from other worlds by individuals (such as Tagomi and Kotomishi) who are able to travel via meditation. The leaders of the Nazis and the Resistance are trying to find one that shows how to avoid nuclear Armageddon.

The Man in the High Castle

is Hawthorne Abendsen, a leader of the West Coast resistance, who maintains a large collection of films

Some knowledge of the book may give a greater understanding.

Clearly the plots do not directly follow each other, and the most obvious difference is that in the book, The Grasshopper Lies Heavy is a book, whereas in the series it is a series of motion pictures*. However, if we assume the central premise is the same then

the world portrayed is a fiction, and the films exist to reveal to the characters that they are not real

In such an interpretation, it does not really matter who "the man" is, or what the in-universe motivations are.

On the other hand, I believe there is not intended to be a definitive answer and the audience is free to come to their own conclusions. Your own explanation is perfectly reasonable, but I prefer one based on a multiverse theory of realities, where the films slip through from other realities

like Tagomi does in the final scene

and Hitler is "the man" (his residence is the only thing presented that could qualify as a literal "high castle") collecting them in order to understand the various possibilities and steer history to his design.

*Crucially, it is the same medium in which story is presented to us.

Some knowledge of the book may give a greater understanding.

Clearly the plots do not directly follow each other, and the most obvious difference is that in the book, The Grasshopper Lies Heavy is a book, whereas in the series it is a series of motion pictures*. However, if we assume the central premise is the same then

the world portrayed is a fiction, and the films exist to reveal to the characters that they are not real

In such an interpretation, it does not really matter who "the man" is, or what the in-universe motivations are.

On the other hand, I believe there is not intended to be a definitive answer and the audience is free to come to their own conclusions. Your own explanation is perfectly reasonable, but I prefer one based on a multiverse theory of realities, where the films slip through from other realities

like Tagomi does in the final scene

and Hitler is "the man" (his residence is the only thing presented that could qualify as a literal "high castle") collecting them in order to understand the various possibilities and steer history to his design.

*Crucially, it is the same medium in which story is presented to us.


As of season two, we have definitive answers. The films

are brought from other worlds by individuals (such as Tagomi and Kotomishi) who are able to travel via meditation. The leaders of the Nazis and the Resistance are trying to find one that shows how to avoid nuclear Armageddon.

The Man in the High Castle

is Hawthorne Abendsen, a leader of the West Coast resistance, who maintains a large collection of films

added 8 characters in body
Source Link
OrangeDog
  • 4.2k
  • 1
  • 25
  • 29
Loading
Source Link
OrangeDog
  • 4.2k
  • 1
  • 25
  • 29
Loading